The Quiet Social Security Rule That Penalizes Widows Who Remarry Too Soon

Remarrying after losing a spouse can be an exciting step forward, but Social Security has one timing rule that could affect the survivor benefit you already receive. Depending on when you remarry, that monthly check could stop, and the cutoff comes down to your age.

It is one of those surprising retirement mistakes that can be easy to make simply because the rule is not widely known. Knowing where Social Security draws the line can help you plan your next chapter without an unexpected change to your monthly income.

Find Out: 13 moves seniors could benefit from but often forget about.

Why waiting until 60 can protect your monthly check

If you remarry before age 60, you generally cannot receive survivor benefits on your late spouse’s record while the new marriage continues. Waiting until you reach 60 can preserve your eligibility, which makes the timing especially important if you are close to that birthday.

For example, someone who remarries shortly before 60 could lose access to a survivor benefit they otherwise could have started at that age. Remarrying once you reach the age-60 cutoff generally allows you to collect on your late spouse’s record even after the new marriage begins.

Disabled surviving spouses have an earlier cutoff at age 50, with remarriage before that age generally ending the survivor benefit and remarriage at 50 or later allowing it to continue.

Shopping for cheaper auto insurance? Enter your zip code here to get started.

How much could you lose by remarrying before 60?

Your survivor benefit can be worth up to 100% of your late spouse’s benefit, depending on when you claim. Starting at age 60 generally gives you about 71.5% of their full benefit, with the percentage increasing if you wait longer to claim.

If your late spouse’s full benefit was $2,500 a month, claiming at 60 could give you about $1,788 a month, or roughly $21,450 a year. Remarry before 60, and you could lose that survivor benefit, adding up to more than $200,000 over 10 years if you would otherwise have received it that entire time.

Even a smaller monthly benefit can add up to a large amount over several years. With the average surviving spouse receiving about $1,933 a month, losing that payment for five years would add up to nearly $116,000.

Losing the benefit does not always mean losing it forever

If you remarry before 60 and lose your survivor benefit, you may be able to get it back if that marriage later ends. Social Security can generally restore your eligibility after a divorce or the death of your new spouse.

For example, someone who remarries at 55 and divorces at 63 could become eligible again for survivor benefits on the first spouse’s record. They generally would not receive benefits retroactively for the period after age 60 when the second marriage made them ineligible, but they could become re-entitled once that marriage ends.

Save Money: Things to cut when living on retirement (many people ignore #11)

Why your own work record may not make up the difference

If you qualify for both your own retirement benefit and a survivor benefit, you generally cannot collect both full payments at once. Social Security can pay an amount up to the higher benefit, and you may also have the option to take one benefit first and switch to the other later.

If your late spouse earned more than you did during their career, the survivor benefit could be hundreds of dollars higher than what your own work record provides. Losing that survivor benefit because you remarried too early would not make your retirement benefit larger, so you could be left with much less Social Security income each month.

The gap can be even bigger if you spent only a few years working in jobs covered by Social Security. In that case, your own benefit may be fairly small, making the survivor benefit a much larger part of the income you count on each month.

What to check before you set a date

Before you choose a wedding date, it is worth checking exactly how Social Security’s remarriage rule applies to you.

• Confirm your cutoff age: For most surviving spouses, the cutoff is 60, while disabled surviving spouses have an earlier cutoff at 50. Social Security counts the month you reach that age, so you generally do not need to wait until the following month.

• Check how much income is at stake: Your my Social Security account at ssa.gov can help you compare your survivor benefit with the retirement benefit available on your own work record. You can also call Social Security at 1-800-772-1213 if you need help confirming the amount.

If waiting a few months could protect a survivor benefit worth $20,000 or more a year, knowing the numbers before you set the date can make the decision much easier.

Bottom line

If remarriage is part of your future, knowing this Social Security rule gives you time to work it into your retirement plan before you set a date. Waiting until you reach the right age could help you keep a survivor benefit worth thousands of dollars a year while still moving forward with the life you want.

Once you know your cutoff age and how much your benefit is worth, you can make the choice that works best for you. A little planning can help you protect that income and start your next chapter with one less financial worry.

More from FinanceBuzz: