Target Will Open Another Store. A 62-Year-Old New Hire Can Cross Social Security’s Annual Limit and Still Keep the Checks From the Months He Was Retired
A retired machinist takes a part-time job at a new Target and watches his annual earnings sail past the Social Security limit, raising a question most retirees never think to ask until the agency sends a letter demanding money back.
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A 62-year-old Albuquerque machinist wraps up a 30-year career in March and files for Social Security benefits to begin in April. By late summer, the yard work is done, the grandkids are back in school, and he spots a part-time opening at Target (NYSE:TGT | TGT Price Prediction). The retailer is expanding in his city, with plans reported for a 128,000-square-foot store on the Westside, and the timing feels right.
He takes the job. Then a familiar worry creeps in: will Social Security claw back the checks he already received? A version of this question shows up frequently on retiree forums, usually phrased as, “I retired in March and started collecting. If I go back to work in September, do I owe all those benefits back?” The answer, in his first benefit year, is usually no, and the reason is a rule most people have never heard of.
Why the Annual Test Feels Unfair in a Transition Year
Anyone under full retirement age (FRA) for all of 2026 can earn $24,480 before Social Security starts withholding $1 for every $2 above that line. The catch: the annual test counts every dollar earned in the calendar year, including wages collected before he ever filed.
Say his old employer paid him $18,000 from January through March. Add $3,500 a month from Target from September through December, or $14,000, and 2026 wages hit $32,000. That is $7,520 over the limit, which on its face would trigger withheld benefits. For a worker who was genuinely retired for five straight months, that feels like a penalty for taking a job.
First-Year Rule Grades His Calendar Month by Month
Social Security recognizes the awkwardness of a mid-year retirement. In the first year someone claims benefits, the agency can apply a special monthly earnings test instead of the annual one. In 2026, a person below FRA is treated as retired during any whole month in which wages come in at $2,040 or less and no substantial self-employment work is performed.
Run his calendar against that standard:
- January through March. He earned $18,000 before filing. Those months do not qualify as retired, but he was not collecting benefits yet, so nothing is at risk.
- April through August. Zero wages. Each of these five months counts as a retired month, and the Social Security checks paid for them are protected even though his annual total will end up above the limit.
- September through December. Target pays roughly $3,500 a month, which clears the $2,040 line. These months do not qualify, and benefits for them can be withheld.
The rule protects specific months. It does not erase the Target paychecks or shrink the annual total. It simply says the five quiet months in the middle should not be undone because the calendar year ended busier than it started.
How It Fits With the Rest of His Retirement Picture
The special rule is a one-time cushion. In 2027, if he keeps working at Target, the ordinary annual test generally applies to the full year unless he reaches full retirement age during it. Once he hits FRA at 67, the earnings test disappears entirely and wages no longer shrink his check.
A second piece worth watching: any benefits Social Security withholds are not truly lost. At the full age threshold, the agency recalculates and credits back the months that were withheld, nudging his monthly benefit up for life. And the 2027 cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) is tracking near the mid-3% range, which will lift whatever base he ends up with.
What to Do Before the First Target Paycheck Clears
Two practical moves make the difference between smooth handling and a confusing letter next spring.
- Call Social Security when the Target job starts, give a realistic estimate of total 2026 wages, and confirm the first-year monthly test will be applied.
- Then keep the last pay stubs from the old job and the first stubs from Target so wages can be assigned to the correct months if anyone asks.
The annual total will say he earned too much. The calendar will show when he was genuinely retired. In a first benefit year, that distinction is what preserves the checks he already spent.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.