[For those hesitant about individual government bonds] Should you have bought in October? Will interest rates rise in December? How to stop overthinking the 'best time to buy'
Hello.
I am Komatsu, a cram school teacher and financial planner.
The following question was trending on Yahoo! Chiebukuro.
“The interest rate for individual government bonds dropped in November. I should have bought in October. Is there any sign that rates will rise in December or January?”
I understand the feeling of wishing you had bought back then.
Especially since the October offering was reported as having the ‘highest interest rate ever,’ which makes it even more frustrating.
Many people may feel like they missed the best time to buy and are losing out.
Let me give you the conclusion first.
-
No one knows whether interest rates will rise or fall in December or January. The Ministry of Finance does not announce this in advance.
-
The difference between October and November for 1 million yen held for 5 years is about 9,000 yen (after tax). Not buying at all makes a much bigger difference.
-
Individual government bonds are issued every month. Rather than trying to guess the best time to buy, it is less stressful to divide your purchases based on when you plan to use the money.
Today, based on official information from the Ministry of Finance, I will explain how interest rates are determined and how to think about the ‘best time to buy’.
Please note that this article does not recommend any specific product!
What is the difference between October and November?
According to the Ministry of Finance website, the interest rates for the November offering are as follows (as of November 6, Reiwa 8):
・Floating 10-year: 1.85% per annum
・Fixed 5-year: 2.17% per annum
・Fixed 3-year: 1.94% per annum
According to reports, the decrease from the October offering was 0.20% for the floating 10-year, 0.22% for the fixed 5-year, and 0.13% for the fixed 3-year.
The October interest rates were this much higher compared to November.
・Floating 10-year was about 2.05% (+0.20%)
・Fixed 5-year was about 2.39% (+0.22%)
・Fixed 3-year was about 2.07% (+0.13%)
So, how much does this difference actually amount to?
Calculation: If you hold 1 million yen at a fixed rate (before and after taxes)
Fixed 5-year (0.22% difference): 11,000 yen over 5 years. Approximately 8,770 yen after tax
Fixed 3-year (0.13% difference): 3,900 yen over 3 years. Approximately 3,110 yen after tax
The feeling of ‘I should have bought in October’ is a matter of a few thousand to just under 10,000 yen on a 1 million yen investment
On the other hand, the difference compared to a bank savings account (reported at around 0.5% per year at mega-banks) should be much larger
Comparing 1 million yen over 5 years, a 5-year fixed rate (2.17% per year) yields about 108,000 yen in interest (before tax)
At a 0.5% savings account rate, it is about 25,000 yen
Rather than obsessing over the ‘best time to buy,’ the difference in ‘where you put your money’ is far greater
How are interest rates determined?
It is clearly stated that the interest rates for Japanese Government Bonds for Individuals are determined as follows
Floating 10-year
Interest rate = Base rate × 0.66 (minimum 0.05% per year). Reviewed every six months
The base rate is the average yield of 10-year government bond auctions. It is reviewed every six monthsFixed 5-year
Interest rate = Base rate – 0.05%
The base rate is the projected yield calculated based on market interest rates two business days before the start of the offering periodFixed 3-year
Interest rate = Base rate – 0.03%
The method of determination is the same as the 5-year fixed rate (for a 3-year period)
I hope you now understand that this ‘base rate’ is important
The interest rates for Japanese Government Bonds for Individuals move in tandem with ‘long-term interest rates’ in the market
If long-term interest rates fall, the interest rate for these bonds also falls
If they rise, they rise
Furthermore, long-term interest rates fluctuate daily due to various factors, such as Bank of Japan decisions, U.S. interest rates, the economy, and stock market movements
Predicting this in advance is difficult even for professionals
What will happen in December? What we know
-
The offering period for December is December 7th to 30th (scheduled by the Ministry of Finance)
-
Starting with the December offering (201st issue), the name will change to ‘Japanese Government Bonds for Individuals Plus,’ and the target for sales will expand to include some corporations (Ministry of Finance). This does not mean that individuals will be unable to buy them
-
The interest rate for December is determined shortly before the offering begins. It is impossible to definitively say whether it will ‘rise’ or ‘fall’ in advance
If you wait thinking ‘it might rise next month’ and it falls
That kind of thing happens all the time
Komatsu’s approach: Choose based on ‘when you will use the money’ rather than ‘when to buy’
Finally, I would like to share my stance
Japanese Government Bonds for Individuals are issued every month
Therefore, there is no need to try to hit the perfect time to buy in one go
● Choose the term by working backward from when you will use the money
→ If you will use it in 3 years, choose the 3-year fixed rate. If in 5 years, the 5-year fixed rate.● Instead of investing the full amount at once, split it into several purchases
→ For example, if you buy in three separate installments, you can avoid putting the entire amount in at the lowest point.● Assume that you cannot cash it in for one year
→ Keep your living expense reserves separate.
Hypothetical example: Buying 3 million yen in three installments with a 5-year fixed rate (interest rates are purely hypothetical figures).
-
1st time: 2.0% per year, 2nd time: 2.3% per year, 3rd time: 2.6% per year → Average of 2.3% per year.
-
If you put the full amount in during the lowest month: 2.0% per year.
-
If you put the full amount in during the highest month: 2.6% per year.
By splitting it up, you can reduce the risk of putting the entire amount in during the worst month.
Conversely, you also reduce the chance of putting the entire amount in during the best month.
This is what it means to ‘split it up’.
There is also the school of thought that says, ‘If interest rates look like they will rise, it is better to wait.’
However, I believe that deciding when you need the money and calmly buying in installments leads to less regret.
Three common misconceptions
Misconception 1
・It is decided whether interest rates will rise or fall each month.
→ They change every month in line with long-term interest rates.
→ They cannot be known in advance.
Misconception 2
・People who bought in October hit the jackpot.
→ The difference is only a few thousand to just under 10,000 yen per 1 million yen.
→ Whether it matches when you need the money is more important.
Misconception 3
・Individuals cannot buy the December ‘Individual Government Bond Plus’.
→ Individuals can still buy them as before.
→ The target audience is simply being expanded to include some corporations, etc.
Summary
-
The interest rates for the November offering are 1.85% for 10-year variable, 2.17% for 5-year fixed, and 1.94% for 3-year fixed. The difference compared to October is about 9,000 yen (after tax) for 1 million yen held for 5 years.
-
Interest rates are determined in line with long-term interest rates and cannot be predicted in advance. The December offering is from December 7th to 30th. The name is changing to ‘Individual Government Bond Plus’, but individuals can still buy them.
-
Rather than trying to guess the right time to buy, choose the term by working backward from when you will use the money, and buy in several installments. Assume you cannot cash it in for one year, and keep your living expense reserves separate.
Finally
‘How much should I keep in government bonds versus savings in my case?’
‘What term should I buy for education expenses?’
The answers to these questions change depending on when you need the money and your household’s financial situation.
If you are unsure, please feel free to consult with Komatsu via LINE.
Let’s organize your situation together.