Bad News for Short Sellers: Nvidia Will “Return All Excess Free Cash Flow” at About 10x Earnings
Key Takeaways
-
NVIDIA returned a record $28 billion to shareholders last quarter and now plans to return all its excess free cash flow, net of strategic uses.
-
That’s bad news for short sellers, since NVIDIA is buying back stock at the lowest multiple on its five-year chart.
-
At today’s multiple, the $227 billion left on its buyback would retire about $17.7 billion of next year’s earnings, nearly 3x what it would at its five-year average.
-
The main risk is NVIDIA’s $390 billion of purchase commitments.
NVIDIA (NVDA:NASDAQ) returned a record $28 billion to shareholders in its fiscal third quarter, and it just promised to return even more.
On Tuesday’s third-quarter call, interim CEO and CFO Colette Kress said NVIDIA intends to “return all excess free cash flow, net of strategic uses, to shareholders during this last quarter and going forward.”
Warren Pies, co-founder of 3Fourteen Research, summed it up in a post on X: “Who knows where $NVDA is going, but I would not want to be short with this monster buyback looming.”
Hard to argue with that.
There’s plenty of cash to go around
The $28 billion was $22 billion of buybacks and $6 billion of dividends. During the quarter, the board added $150 billion to the buyback. NVIDIA ended the quarter with $227 billion left, and it plans to use all of it by the end of fiscal 2028, which ends in January 2028.
Analysts expect the cash behind that buyback to keep growing fast:
Free cash flow was $96.7 billion in fiscal 2026, and consensus has about $332 billion for fiscal 2028. That year alone tops the $227 billion left, so if NVIDIA keeps Kress’s pledge, I’d expect the board to add to the buyback before it runs out.
TIKR tracks 63 analysts on Nvidia. How many say “Buy”?
See the full breakdown of Buy, Hold, and Sell ratings on Nvidia, along with Wall Street’s revenue and earnings estimates, all in one place. More than 500,000 investors use TIKR to research stocks like this one. See Nvidia’s Analyst Ratings
13x is a great price to buy back stock
The selloff has left NVIDIA at the cheapest multiple on its five-year chart:
NVIDIA trades at about 13x forward earnings. Its five-year average is about 36x, and it peaked near 70x in May 2023.
Every dollar spent on a buyback buys a slice of next year’s earnings. Spent at today’s multiple, the full $227 billion would retire about $17.7 billion of next year’s earnings, against about $6.4 billion at the five-year average. (The price won’t sit still while NVIDIA buys, of course, but the gap is enormous.)
Fewer shares means faster EPS growth
NVIDIA’s diluted share count was already falling before last quarter’s record:
The count fell from 24.8 billion in the quarter to October 2024 to 24.3 billion in the quarter to July 2026, about 2%, bought at much higher multiples. At about a third of its five-year average multiple, NVIDIA can cut the count much faster from here.
Suppliers come first
Kress’s pledge has a qualifier: “net of strategic uses.” On the call, she said NVIDIA’s purchase commitments rose to $390 billion in the third quarter, and “the top priority is going to be our suppliers,” including prepayments to help them add capacity.
If demand cools while those commitments come due, cash handed back today won’t be there. Still, Kress said “there is definitely the room to continue all of the stock repurchases plans that we want to do and complete those before the end of fiscal year ’28.”
I wouldn’t want to be short either
To make money from here, short sellers need NVIDIA’s earnings to fall a long way. At the end of the day, a company pledging all its excess cash to buybacks at about 13x earnings has a buyer few stocks can match.
A buyback can’t hold up a stock if earnings estimates fall, though. The next test comes with the fourth-quarter report in late February. Revenue near the $130 billion guide, plus buybacks well above the third quarter’s $22 billion, would show that Kress’s pledge is more than talk.
So what is NVIDIA stock actually worth?
TIKR lets you forecast the future price of any stock in less than a minute. Just enter a few assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model and see what NVIDIA could be worth. Start from Wall Street consensus estimates, or adjust the inputs to reflect your own view of the business. It’s free to use.