Nasdaq turns negative: Why Anthropic & other tech stocks are getting crushed
00:00 Speaker A
The Nasdaq is now negative for the year, and the AI trade is leading the way down. Now, the slump started in early October right after the index hit an all-time high.
00:10 Speaker A
There’s plenty feeding into this from a fed that is talking about raising rates to the fight over data centers after the midterms, but there’s a disconnect in chips specifically, which is what I want to talk about today.
00:24 Speaker A
The stocks are falling hard, but chip sales, they are at record levels, almost two and a half times what they were a year ago. and that’s largely been the narrative of the year.
00:32 Speaker A
My read now though is that that power is shifting away from the companies that sell AI chips and toward the big companies that buy them, like Google and Anthropic.
00:41 Speaker A
Now to be clear, both sides are down today. Anthropic is falling right along with the chip makers, but what I’m looking at next is how the market is starting to think about who wins this over time.
00:52 Speaker A
Start with Google. It designs its own AI chips with help from Broadcom. This morning, analyst Ming Chi Kuo reported that Google cut about 20% of those chips from next year’s plans and is moving some orders to a rival, MediaTek.
01:04 Speaker A
Now, neither company has confirmed it, and Broadcom shares down more than 10% today. Now, Anthropic is using its own position as a buyer in its own way.
01:13 Speaker A
Its models, they run on chips already from several different makers, so no one supplier has it locked in. It has actually diversified itself.
01:21 Speaker A
Before the IPO, Dario Amade told Jamie Diamond that he deliberately buys less compute up front than he might need.
01:29 Speaker A
So if demand runs hot, he buys more at the last minute. Now, this has surprised me because Open AI has really done the opposite when it comes to compute.
01:39 Speaker A
It locked up huge amounts of computing power early, and that allowed it to clo close much of the intelligence gap with Anthropic this year.
01:45 Speaker A
Anthropic even admitted in its own IPO filing that it significantly underestimated how much computing power it needed. and that actually set back its products this year.
01:54 Speaker A
So I asked investor Anj Mato, why Dario would stick with this approach, especially when everyone is saying they’re compute constrained.
02:02 Speaker A
Well, Mato was one of Anthropic’s earliest backers. His company also sells this kind of last-minute computing power, so he does have a stake in all of this.
02:08 Speaker A
His answer is that AI research is spiky. So a lab runs small experiments and when one works, it suddenly needs thousands of more chips.
02:16 Speaker A
If you buy enough to cover every single spike, a lot of those chips, they just sit idle the rest of the time. When I asked him if we are in an AI bubble, he called it a GPU wastage bubble, meaning that a lot of the chips being bought are not getting used.
02:30 Speaker A
If that is right, that is a problem for the companies that are selling them, and it helps explain why their stocks are falling while these sales are hitting records.
02:37 Speaker A
Now, none of this is showing up in at least Nvidia’s profits yet, and Anthropic still has about 900 billion in long-term computing commitments.
02:46 Speaker A
A lot of that going to the same chip makers. So, two things to watch going forward. If the buyers really are gaining the upper hand, Nvidia’s margins, the share of each sale it keeps as profit, that should start to slip and Anthropic’s costs should start to fall.
03:00 Speaker A
That is when you might expect these stocks to stop moving together.