He Makes $150,000 on a 2x Anthropic ETF in December at Age 65 and Loses $140,000 in January. The Gain Lands in One Tax Year, the Loss in the Next, and $15,900 More of His …
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
Take a hypothetical a 65-year-old who collects about $2,000 a month from Social Security. He also takes $22,000 a year from his IRA.
Suppose he makes a $150,000 gain on a 2x leveraged Anthropic fund in December and sells. In January he buys back in, the fund falls, and he sells again at a $140,000 loss.
Over six weeks he is ahead by about $10,000. His tax returns show the gain in one year and the loss in the next.
That timeline is now realistic. Tradr’s 2x Long Anthropic Daily ETF (ANTT) is set to begin trading on Cboe on November 23, 2026, and the SEC is keeping its 2x limit on leveraged funds. A fund that doubles each day’s move can double the losses just as fast. That is how a retiree ends up owing tax on money he no longer has.
One Calendar Page Decides How Much of His Benefit Gets Taxed
The IRS decides how much of your benefit check to tax using what it calls provisional income: your other income plus half of your benefits. For a single filer, benefits start to become taxable above $25,000, and more of each dollar counts above $34,000. No matter how high your income goes, no more than 85% of your benefits is assessed.
Before the trade, his provisional income is $34,000. That is his IRA withdrawal plus half of his $24,000 in yearly benefits. At that level, only $4,500 of his Social Security counts as taxable income.
Add a $150,000 gain and he hits the ceiling. Now 85% of his benefits, or $20,400, is taxable.
That is $15,900 more Social Security taxed in 2026, all because of a trade he gave back a few weeks later.
He held the shares for less than a year, so the gain is short-term and assessed like ordinary income. His taxable income comes to about $174,250, which puts him in the 24% bracket for single filers. At that rate, the extra Social Security alone costs roughly $3,816 in federal tax.
Why January’s Loss Can’t Reach Back Into December
Each tax year is counted separately. The $140,000 loss from his January sale goes on his 2027 return. There it first cancels out any capital gains, and after that it can reduce other income by only $3,000[1] a year.
The unused $137,000 carries forward. If he never has another capital gain, using it up at that rate would take more than 45 years.
Now picture both trades landing in the same year. A net $10,000 gain would raise his provisional income to $44,000, and $13,000 would be taxable from his benefits.
That is $8,500 more taxable Social Security instead of $15,900, and he would still be under the 85% ceiling.
Costs That Show Up a Year or Two Later
The gain also costs him the new $6,000 senior deduction. It shrinks by 6% of income above $75,000, and at his income it goes away completely.
At his 24% rate, losing it adds about $1,440 to what he owes.
Medicare comes later. Part B premiums are based on income from 2 years prior, so this December’s gain will affect what he pays in 2028. His adjusted gross income for 2026 comes to about $192,400.
For comparison, the 2026 standard Part B premium is $203 a month. Surcharges for single filers start once income tops $109,000. The 2028 brackets will be different, but his income would be well past where the surcharges start today.
Set Aside the Tax Before the Next Trade Turns
The mistake that is hardest to undo is reinvesting December’s gain as if all of it were yours. The tax is fixed on December 31, whatever January brings. If you sell a leveraged fund at a short-term profit, set away money for the tax the same day. That gain also makes more of your benefits taxable and can raise your Medicare premiums down the road.
A large late-year gain can also call for an estimated tax payment. The IRS says you may be charged a penalty even if you are due a refund when you underpay during the year. The leftover loss still has value: it can cancel out future gains dollar for dollar, so keep good records of it. This provisional-income trap is one of several quiet rules that drain retirement accounts, and we cataloged the rest in a free report on retiree tax traps.
These figures assume a single filer with no state income tax. The presence of a spouse, pension or different benefit amount would change the results, so run your own numbers before your next large sale.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.