Is Adding Gold To Your Portfolio A Fool’s Gold Move?
Mike Zaino, of The Zaino Group, is a Registered Financial Consultant and National Retirement Counselor serving federal and postal employees.
When it comes to investing, gold has a certain allure. After all, it’s shiny, it’s been a symbol of wealth for centuries, and let’s face it—pirates didn’t draw treasure maps to ETFs. But is gold really a wise addition to your portfolio, or is it just an overrated hunk of metal that will make you say, “Argh, what was I thinking?” Let’s dive into the reasons why gold might not be the glittering investment you imagine.
Gold Doesn’t Work For You
Imagine hiring someone who shows up to work every day but doesn’t actually do anything. They just sit there, shiny and impressive but unproductive. That’s gold. Unlike stocks, which can grow in value and pay you dividends, or fixed index annuities, which only increase in value and are designed to pay out a guaranteed lifetime income stream, gold doesn’t earn compound interest or gain value quickly. It just sits there in your portfolio looking pretty and does little to make you richer over the long term.
Sure, it might appreciate in value if the market decides it’s time for a gold rush or if economic instability or geopolitical conflict continues, but that’s speculative. Meanwhile, your productive investments are out there hustling, compounding interest and making your money grow.
The Price Roller Coaster
Gold is often called a “safe haven” investment, but let’s not confuse “safe” with “stable.” Gold prices can swing wildly, driven by global events, investor sentiment and even plain old fear. One minute, everyone wants gold because the world seems to be falling apart; the next, they’ve moved on to the latest hot stock or crypto trend.
MORE FOR YOU
If you’re looking for stability, gold’s volatility might have you clutching your pearls. And if you’re someone who checks their portfolio obsessively, watching gold’s ups and downs might give you whiplash.
The Long-Term Snooze Fest
Here’s a not-so-fun fact: Over the long term, gold has historically underperformed other investments like stocks. Sure, gold might keep up with inflation over decades, but stocks often leave it in the dust, offering significantly higher returns.
If your goal is to grow wealth over time, gold’s unimpressive long-term performance can make it feel like the tortoise that forgot it was supposed to be racing the hare. While your other investments are sprinting ahead, gold’s just moseying along, waving at the crowd.
The Opportunity Cost
Investing is all about putting your money to work and capitalizing on the best returns. By investing in gold, you’re locking up your cash in an asset that doesn’t generate much additional income or drive growth. That’s cash you could have invested in a diversified stock portfolio, real estate or even a small business venture.
Think of it this way: If your money were a basketball team, gold would be the player who refuses to shoot, pass or defend. Do you really want that kind of dead weight on your roster?
Owning Gold Can Be A Hassle
If you’re buying physical gold, you’ve got to figure out where to store it. A shoebox under your bed? Risky. A fancy safe? Expensive. Even gold ETFs or mutual funds come with management fees, which can eat into your returns over time.
Plus, if you’re someone who tends to misplace things, losing a gold coin could be a very expensive mistake. At least if you lose your stock certificates, they’re just a phone call away (assuming you don’t invest like it’s 1929 and actually use paper certificates).
Gold: The Drama Queen Of Investments
Gold doesn’t play by the usual investment rules. Stocks and bonds are influenced by factors like earnings reports, interest rates and economic growth. Gold? In my experience, it’s all about sentiment—the attractive shiny new object. Some people buy gold because they think others will buy gold, which can make its value feel a bit like a game of musical chairs. And when the music stops, you don’t want to be the one left holding the bag (or in this case, the gold bar).
Inflation Hedge? Not Always
Gold is often marketed as a hedge against inflation, and while it can perform well during certain inflationary periods, it’s not a magic bullet—or the only option. For example, real estate has historically provided good inflation protection over the long term, and as a real estate investor myself, I’ve enjoyed the benefit of income-producing assets through the rents I collect and also benefit from capital appreciation.
If inflation is your concern, diversifying with a mix of asset classes is usually a more reliable strategy than betting heavily on gold.
It Might Not Improve Your Portfolio
Diversification is the name of the game in investing. The idea is to spread your money across distinct types of assets so that if one underperforms, others can pick up the slack. While gold can add some diversification, its benefits might be marginal if your portfolio already includes assets like cash, which often provides a cushion against stock market downturns.
Adding gold might end up being the investment equivalent of putting pineapple on pizza. Sure, some people love it, but others find it unnecessary and downright questionable.
When Gold Might Make Sense
To be fair, gold isn’t all bad. If you’re worried about the collapse of the financial system (or planning to join a post-apocalyptic barter economy), gold might be worth considering. Certainly, there are both pros and cons. But for the average investor focused on building wealth over the long term, in my experience, it’s usually not the most efficient choice.
The Bottom Line
Investing in gold might sound glamorous, but its drawbacks often outweigh its benefits. It doesn’t reliably generate income, it can be volatile, and its long-term returns pale in comparison to other assets. Plus, the opportunity cost of holding gold can be significant, as your money could be working harder elsewhere.
Does this mean you should never own gold? Not necessarily. A small allocation (think 5% or less) might make sense for some investors as part of a diversified portfolio. But if you’re thinking of going all in on gold, it’s worth asking yourself: Are you chasing a shiny illusion, or are you building a strategy that truly works for your future?
So, the next time someone tries to sell you gold as the ultimate investment, just remember: All that glitters isn’t gold—and all that’s gold might not glitter as brightly as a well-diversified portfolio.
The information provided here is not investment, tax or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation.
Forbes Finance Council is an invitation-only organization for executives in successful accounting, financial planning and wealth management firms. Do I qualify?