Social Security and income tax: New deduction favors wealthy
A newly implemented $6,000 tax deduction for older people is being promoted as a major tax break for retirees—but the benefits are skewed toward higher-income households, and the change may actually weaken the long-term solvency of the Social Security and Medicare trust funds.
New rule doesn’t help most low-income retirees
The new law, enacted under the Trump administration, offers a $6,000 income deduction for taxpayers 65 and older, which slightly lowers taxable income—including Social Security benefits—through 2028. However, this does not eliminate taxation on benefits, despite recent political claims to the contrary.
According to policy experts at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP):
- Nearly half of retirees already paid no income tax, meaning the deduction provides no new relief for most low- and middle-income retirees.
- The deduction excludes younger Social Security beneficiaries, such as those on disability, early retirees, or survivors under 65.
Instead, the largest benefits will go to wealthier older people:
- Nearly two-thirds of the deduction’s benefits will go to households earning between $80,000 and $270,000.
- For these groups, the law slightly reduces—but does not eliminate—taxes on Social Security.
Trust funds take a hit
Beyond who benefits, analysts warn the new rules threaten the solvency of both Social Security and Medicare:
- Roughly 60% of taxes on Social Security benefits go to the retirement trust fund; the rest supports Medicare.
- The new deduction, combined with other permanent tax cuts, is expected to slash Social Security tax revenue by $30 billion per year.
- This could accelerate trust fund depletion to 2032, one year earlier than previously projected.
Had the administration fully repealed taxation of Social Security benefits—as previously promised—it would have cost $1.5 trillion over ten years.
Misleading communications spark confusion
Critics say the Social Security Administration (SSA) helped spread confusion by sending an email claiming that “nearly 90% of older people will no longer pay income taxes on their Social Security.”
However, this overstates the deduction’s impact:
- Taxes on benefits are still tied to other income sources like wages, IRA withdrawals, and dividends.
- Many retirees will still owe some tax, even with the deduction.
- Confused taxpayers may stop withholding or estimating tax payments, leading to surprises during tax season.
The SSA’s email also risks damaging trust in the agency, as some recipients may unsubscribe from future updates after feeling misled.
What’s next for Social Security?
While the administration portrays the deduction as a win for older people, experts warn of long-term costs:
- Lower-income retirees receive little to no benefit.
- Vital trust funds are weakened at a time of rising retiree populations.
- Public confusion grows due to politicized and inaccurate messaging.
Meanwhile, calls are growing for more sustainable and equitable reforms to protect future benefits without shifting more burdens onto the most vulnerable.
More news from FL1: