S&P 500: Powell’s Tone and Yield Curve May Steer Market Reaction to Fed Cut

Historically, Fed easing cycles have bolstered stocks. Since 1982, the S&P 500 has posted gains in 8 of 10 such periods, averaging nearly 11% returns over the following 12 months. Today’s backdrop—resilient GDP, stable financial conditions, and still-growing large-cap earnings—mirrors past soft-landing scenarios.

Strategists like Brian Belski argue these conditions favor risk assets, particularly small-caps, which have lagged but trade at a steep discount. The S&P Small Cap 600 sports a forward P/E of 15.5 versus 22.7 for the S&P 500, positioning them as prime beneficiaries of easing credit conditions.

Sector rotation may also gain steam. Real estate, consumer discretionary, and tech stocks—historically strong performers during easing phases—could see renewed buying. Lower borrowing costs are a direct tailwind to these segments, especially as capital becomes more accessible and valuations are reassessed.

Are There Parallels to 2007’s Misstep?

Not everyone is convinced. Critics point to similarities with the 2007 cycle, when rate cuts failed to avert recession but did stoke inflation. Doug Ramsey of Leuthold Group warns that lower short-term rates today may push long-term yields higher if inflation expectations break loose. With CPI still near 3.3% and wholesale prices elevated, inflation remains a critical risk factor.

Adding to concerns, labor market data has softened. Unemployment claims have hit their highest levels since 2021, and payrolls have been revised lower. David Bianco of DWS questions the logic of easing when inflation remains well above target—arguing it signals reactive, rather than proactive, policymaking.

Could High Valuations Magnify Risk?

Equity valuations add another layer of complexity. The S&P 500 is entering this cycle with forward P/E ratios well above historical norms. This leaves limited room for error.