Super Micro Computer (SMCI) Week in Review: 11% Stock Drop Despite 123% Growth

Super Micro Computer (NASDAQ:SMCI | SMCI Price Prediction) dropped 11.2% this week, closing at $30.54 on Friday.

The decline stands out against the broader market’s modest pullback. The S&P 500 (NYSEARCA:SPY) fell 1.3% and the Nasdaq-100 (NASDAQ:QQQ) dropped 1.3% over the same period. Despite the weekly selloff, SMCI remains up 4.3% year-to-date. Three storylines explain what moved the stock this week.

Margin Compression Overshadows Revenue Growth

Super Micro’s Q2 fiscal 2026 results came out on February 3rd and Wall Street continues to ‘digest’ what the company reported.

Super Micro delivered $12.7 billion in revenue, representing 123% year-over-year growth. Wall Street was expecting $10.3 billion in sales, so this was an incredible beat on the top line.

CEO Charles Liang raised the full-year revenue target to $40 billion, calling it “conservative”. The AI server boom is real. But investors aren’t celebrating.

Gross margins compressed to 6.3%, a new low. That’s the problem. Revenue is exploding, but investors are focusing more on compressing margins in an extremely competitive industry. In late 2023, Super Micro had 15.6%gross margins. They slipped below 10% at the beginning of 2025, and are now below 7%.

Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) analyst Katherine Murphy turned bearish, citing margin compression, competitive dynamics, and limited bargaining power versus hyperscaler customers. JR Research downgraded the stock to Hold, warning that intensifying competition from Dell and potential Nvidia offerings pose risks.

Management believes margins will improve through their Data Center Building Block Solutions expansion. But analysts remain skeptical about timing and magnitude. The market is pricing in doubt.

Insider Selling Adds Pressure

Multiple executives and directors sold shares in late November 2025. CEO Charles Liang and 10% owner Sara Liu each disposed of 5,000 shares. Director Sherman Tuan sold 48,630 shares at $33, the largest transaction in the recent period.

The most recent insider activity came on January 29, 2026, when director Tally Liu converted 747 restricted stock units. That’s routine vesting, not conviction buying. According to Nasdaq data, there have been 60 sales across the past year and zero open market buys. Selling isn’t a concern in the sense its very typical for executives to sell shares on plans, but investors watch closely if there’s any insider buying activity. In the case of Super Micro, there is little to be found.

Reddit Sentiment Flipped Bearish

Retail investors on r/wallstreetbets started the week bullish. On Monday, February 9, sentiment scored 74 with a post titled “SMCI (how to make easy money on a hard stock)”. By Thursday evening, sentiment crashed to 25-28 with engagement spiking to 76 upvotes and 33 comments.

The bearish mood persisted through Friday. Sentiment hit its lowest point at 18 on Friday at 6:00 AM. Activity declined as sentiment stabilized, suggesting retail traders discussed the downturn Thursday night then moved on. The pattern shows momentum players abandoning ship when the margin story turned sour.

Super Micro’s AI infrastructure opportunity remains intact. Hyperscalers are spending aggressively, and SMCI sits in the middle of that wave. But the market is demanding proof that revenue growth translates to sustainable profitability. Until margins expand meaningfully, expect volatility to persist.