Should you avoid swing trading? 3 reasons why people say so
You open your brokerage app during your lunch break, only to find your unrealized losses have grown again.
Even during afternoon meetings, those numbers won’t leave your head.
“Maybe this really isn’t for me after all.”
When you look it up online that night, all you see are voices saying, “You should avoid swing trading.”
Have you ever had an experience like that?
Hello, I’m HIRO.
I work as a software engineer in the automotive industry while swing trading on the side.
Let me start with the conclusion.
If you continue without having a set of rules, then “you should avoid it” is correct.
However, that is not because the swing trading method itself is bad.
The reason many people stumble is that they are “making decisions on the fly.”
If you change just this one thing, there is a path to continuing calmly even while working another job.
Reasons why people say you should avoid it
Stock swing trading is often told to be avoided for one reason or another.
First, let’s look at the substance of that.
Swing trading is a type of transaction where you hold stocks for several days to several weeks.
You aim for profits from the waves of price movement during that time.
While you don’t have to be glued to the screen like in day trading, there are points where you are likely to stumble.
Reason 1: Trading based on emotion
A common pattern is buying because it “feels like it might go up.”
When it goes down, you pray for it to “come back,” and when it goes up a little, you get scared and sell.
If you repeat this, your losses tend to be large and your profits small.
Reason 2: Worrying about it even while at work
If you go to work while holding stocks, you’ll worry about the price movements, right?
You secretly open the app in the restroom. You can’t focus on the content of your meetings.
You can’t concentrate on your main job or your investments, and both end up half-baked.
This is one of the reasons why it is said to be “unsuitable for those with a side job.”
Reason 3: Being swayed by events at night or on weekends
In swing trading, you hold stocks through the night and over the weekend.
Due to earnings announcements or movements in overseas markets, the stock price might have moved significantly by the next morning.
If you face this without any preparation, it will take time to recover your composure.
Systems, Not Willpower
All three of these are things that easily make you feel like it’s because your willpower is weak.
I feel pathetic for not being able to cut my losses (confirming a loss and letting go).
I made the same mistake again.
I think there are many people who blame themselves night after night like that.
However, I don’t think so.
The reason things don’t go well is a matter of systems, not willpower.
People are not good at making calm judgments while their money is decreasing.
This is the same for everyone.
That is precisely why, as long as you are making decisions on the spot, hesitation and regret will not easily disappear.
I myself was a completely terrible investor at first.
I would buy because it looked like it might go up, pray when it went down, and sell out of fear when I made a profit.
My funds just kept decreasing.
Back then, I was agonizing over every single decision on the spot.
And the decisions I made after agonizing were the ones that were most inconsistent when looked at later.
What I Changed
From there, I formed hypotheses, tested them, and corrected them. I repeated this over and over.
What I arrived at was a “pattern” with no flashiness or secret tricks.
The direction is simple.
-
Decide on the conditions for taking profits and exiting before you buy
-
Create rules that lead to the same judgment no matter who looks at them
-
Do nothing on days when the conditions are not met
I check the charts for only 15 minutes a day after I finish work.
I only prepare orders for the next day when the conditions are met.
If they aren’t met, I close the app and return to spending time with my family.
That said, there must be some who think, “I don’t feel like I can follow the rules even if I make them.”
I understand that feeling well.
However, I believe that whether or not you can follow them is determined by the “room for hesitation” rather than the strength of your willpower.
The more ambiguous the rules, the more excuses like “just this once” will creep in.
Conversely, if the rules lead to the same answer no matter who looks at them, the time spent hesitating itself will decrease.
By the way, I have compiled my specific rules in a paid note.
People who are not suited for this
I will draw a line here, honestly.
My method is not suitable for those who want to make a lot of money quickly.
This is because I prioritize surviving in the market over winning continuously.
It is plain, and there are times when I do not trade for days.
Also, if you absolutely cannot accept cutting losses, I think it is okay to stop for a moment.
Cutting losses is not a task to admit defeat.
It is a task to protect your capital so you can participate in the next opportunity.
If you continue without this sinking in, it tends to become painful.
Days with a routine
To be honest, my daily life since I established a routine is plain.
I stopped thinking about stocks during meetings.
The number of times I open the app during lunch break has also decreased.
At night, I finish checking in 15 minutes and spend the rest of the time with my family.
Of course, there are days when I have to cut losses.
Even then, if I can think that I acted according to the rules, I do not have to blame myself.
When small “I did it” moments accumulate, I can stay calm even on days when the market is volatile.
For me, the biggest thing was this sense of security.
One step you can take today
Finally, here is one thing you can do starting today.
Try to recall your most recent trade and write it down on paper.
If “just because” comes up here, that is the starting point for building a system.
Try using it as a hint for improvement rather than as material to blame yourself.
It is not too late to decide whether to stop swing trading after that.
The reasons why people say “you should avoid it” can be minimized through a system, not talent.
I have compiled a “routine” that allows you to make decisions in 15 minutes a day in a paid note
I explain the six steps of market environment, trends, stock selection, buying, selling, and exiting with specific conditions and procedures (Japanese stocks, revised edition).
I have also written about the years I lost and the limits of verification without hiding anything.
▶ Read “The 15-Minute Daily Stock Investment Routine”
First, for free,
I deliver market perspectives and exclusive information that I cannot write on note via LINE.
▶ Register for LINE (free)
*This article is intended for informational purposes based on personal experience and does not recommend the buying or selling of any specific stocks. Please make investment decisions at your own risk. Stock investment carries the risk of loss of principal. This article does not constitute investment advisory or agency services as defined by the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act.