The Big Misconception That ETFs Are Always Safe‼️ The Importance of Investment Rules Learned from the 213A Plunge
November 18, 2026
Hello, this is Stock Run Investor😊
(I usually tweet about my real-time asset strategy on X👇)
📉 The semiconductor ETF 213A is experiencing a significant drop.
I have been accumulating 213A with the expectation of growth in the Japanese semiconductor industry, but
this recent decline prompted me to re-examine the mechanics of ETFs themselves.
What I realized was a major misconception on my part😅
I thought that with an ETF, I could diversify across multiple companies and that the holdings and composition ratios would be reviewed periodically.
However, in reality, investment rules vary significantly depending on the ETF.
This time, I would like to think about my future investment policy for 213A while comparing the four ETFs I hold.
① The four ETFs I hold
Currently, I hold the following ETFs.
🤖 213A | Listed Nikkei Semiconductor
Investment expecting growth in the domestic semiconductor industry
🇯🇵 435A | Japanese Stock Dividend Rotation Strategy
Diversified investment in domestic high-dividend stocks
🏢 2556 | One ETF TSE REIT Index
Diversified investment in the domestic real estate market
🇺🇸 SPYD | US High Dividend Stock ETF
Diversified investment in US high-dividend stocks
Since each has a different investment objective, I thought I was well diversified.
However, this time I will focus not only on the investment targets but also on the investment rules.
② 🤖 213A | Periodic reviews are only conducted once a year
213A is an index-type ETF that aims to track the Nikkei Semiconductor Stock Index.
I checked the “Nikkei Semiconductor Stock Index Calculation Guidelines” published by Nikkei Inc.
📋 Basic Index Rules
・Number of constituent stocks: Generally 30 stocks
・Allocation method: Market capitalization weighted method
・Periodic review: Once a year, at the end of November
・Stock selection reference date: End of October
・Composition ratio cap at periodic review: 15%
・Companies where semiconductors are not the main business: 5%
The important thing here is that the 15% cap does not always apply.
If the stock price of a specific stock surges after a periodic review, that stock’s weighting will increase.
Even if the management company determines it is overvalued, they cannot, in principle, reduce that stock regardless of the index.
This is because the investment objective is to track the index.
While there are rules for temporary exclusion due to delisting, etc., there is no mechanism for agile stock replacement based on normal stock price declines.
③ 😱 Concentration Risk in Kioxia
I checked the composition ratio of 213A as of November 16, 2026.
🥇 Kioxia: 19.54%
🥈 Tokyo Electron: 15.34%
🥉 Advantest: 14.01%
④ Renesas: 7.27%
⑤ Disco: 6.84%
Surprisingly, the top 3 stocks account for 48.89%.
The top 5 stocks account for 63.00%‼️
Although it is diversified across 30 stocks, about half of the assets are concentrated in just 3 stocks.
If Kioxia alone were to fall by 30%, and other stocks remained unchanged, the impact on the entire ETF would be approximately -5.86%.
In a rising market, you can greatly benefit from stocks that are increasing in price.
However, when the market reverses, that concentration becomes a major factor in the decline.
This is a characteristic of the market capitalization-weighted method.
※Composition ratios are based on published PCF data. The impact of the decline is a simple estimate by the author.
④ 🇯🇵 435A | Reviewing High-Dividend Stocks Every Month
435A is an active ETF managed by Daiwa Asset Management.
Unlike 213A, there is no index to track.
📋 Investment Rules
・Selected from TOPIX large-cap and mid-cap stocks
・In principle, targets stocks with dividend rights confirmed within 3 months
・Selected based on next expected dividend yield
・Basic composition is 10 large-cap stocks and 40 mid-cap stocks
・Allocation between large-cap and mid-cap stocks is 7 to 3
・Equal allocation within each category
・Rebalanced at the end of every month in principle
This is a strategy that rotates investment targets according to the timing of dividend rights confirmation.
Regular reviews 12 times a year.
It is a mechanism that continuously reconstructs the portfolio in line with the investment objective of earning dividends.
Of course, this does not mean that declines can be avoided, but I believe it is compatible with my own high-dividend investment strategy😊
⑤ 🇺🇸 SPYD|Selects 80 high-dividend stocks from the S&P 500
SPYD is a high-dividend stock ETF that uses the S&P 500 as its population.
📋 Basic rules of the index
・Selected from S&P 500 constituent stocks
・In principle, the 80 stocks with high dividend yields
・Equal-weight method
・Rebalanced twice a year, in January and July
What I would like to pay particular attention to is the equal allocation mechanism.
In the case of 80 stocks, the composition ratio per stock at the time of rebalancing is approximately 1.25%. Although the ratio changes due to stock price fluctuations, the allocation is adjusted every six months.
It is designed to make it easy to suppress excessive concentration on specific companies.
On the other hand, there are risks such as sector bias toward high-dividend stocks, dividend cuts, and exchange rate fluctuations.
⑥ 🏢 2556|Invest in the entire J-REIT market
2556 is an ETF that aims to track the Tokyo Stock Exchange REIT Index.
📋 Basic rules of the index
・Targets all J-REIT stocks listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange
・Free-float market capitalization weighted method
・Regular review of the free-float ratio is in principle once a year, at the end of July
Like 213A, it is an index-type ETF based on market capitalization.
However, instead of selecting 30 specific stocks, it targets the entire J-REIT market for investment.
Indirect investment in various real estate uses such as offices, housing, logistics facilities, commercial facilities, and hotels is possible.
Of course, caution is required regarding concentration in the real estate market and interest rate hike risks.
⑦ 📊 The Decisive Differences Between 4 ETFs
🔴 213A
→ 30 Semiconductor Stocks, Market Cap Weighted
→ Annual Periodic Review
🟢 435A
→ Strategy Based on 50 High-Dividend Stocks
→ Monthly Rebalancing in Principle
🔵 SPYD
→ Selects 80 Stocks from the S&P 500 in Principle
→ Equal Weighting, Semi-Annual Rebalancing
🟠 2556
→ Invests in the Entire J-REIT Market
→ Free-Float Market Cap Weighted Method
Even among ETFs, the selection methods for investment targets, composition ratios, and review timings are completely different.
A higher frequency of reviews does not necessarily mean it is superior.
However, it is extremely important whether those operational rules align with your investment objectives.
⑧ 📅 Focus on the November 30th 213A Rebalancing
On November 16th, Nikkei Inc. announced this year’s periodic stock replacement.
Implementation Date: November 30, 2026
🟢 New Addition
Japan Micronics (6871)
🔴 Exclusion
TOWA (6315)
Also, the periodic weight adjustment based on the index calculation guidelines is worth noting.
To what extent will the concentration in Kioxia be mitigated?
I would like to check the inclusion ratios from December onwards.
However, if specific stocks rise significantly again after the periodic adjustment, the possibility of increased concentration risk remains.
⑨ 💰 Future Investment Policy for 213A
I intend to secure stable cash flow centered on high-dividend stocks while also capturing asset growth through semiconductor investments.
However, through this investigation, I felt that the positioning of 213A needs to be reconsidered.
Here is the future review policy.
・Temporary suspension of new accumulation and additional purchases
・Confirmation of the end-of-November rebalancing results
・Comparison of index design with other semiconductor ETFs
・Consideration including transition to alternative products
I do not intend to deny the growth of the semiconductor industry.
What I want to review is the method of investing in semiconductors.
⑩ 📝 Lessons from this investment
In the future, when purchasing ETFs, I would like to check the following 6 items.
① Investment target and stock selection criteria
② Calculation method for inclusion ratios
③ Upper limit for individual stock composition ratios
④ Rebalancing frequency
⑤ Conditions for ad-hoc reviews
⑥ Trust fees and dividends
For index-type ETFs, check not only the prospectus but also the calculation guidelines for the underlying index.
This is the major lesson from this time.
Buying an ETF means buying not just the stocks, but the operational rules themselves.
The assumption that ETFs are safe or that they provide diversification is a trap, isn’t it?😅
Even at 55, investment is a daily learning process😊
📚 Reference Materials & Sources
・Nikkei Inc. “Nikkei Semiconductor Stock Index Calculation Guidelines”
https://indexes.nikkei.co.jp/nkave/archives/file/nikkei_semiconductor_stock_index_guidebook_jp.pdf
・Nikkei Inc. “November 16, 2026 Periodic Stock Replacement”
https://indexes.nikkei.co.jp/nkave/archives/news/20261116J_1.pdf
・Minkabu “213A Included Stocks”
https://minkabu.jp/stock/213A/fund_selection
・Daiwa Asset Management “435A Official Special Site”
https://www.daiwa-am.co.jp/etf/special/dividend-rotation/
・S&P Dow Jones Indices “S&P 500 High Dividend Index”
https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/jp/indices/dividends-factors/sp-500-high-dividend-index/
・Japan Exchange Group “2556 Product Overview”
https://www.jpx.co.jp/equities/products/etfs/issues/files/2556-j.pdf
・Japan Exchange Group “Regarding the Calculation of Free-Float Ratios for the TSE REIT Index, etc.”
https://www.jpx.co.jp/rules-participants/public-comment/detail/d3/nlsgeu000001zmxp-att/ap_j.pdf
※This article is a personal investment record and analysis, and does not recommend the buying or selling of specific stocks.