[11/18] US Stock Risk Premium Vanishes: The Significance of Earnings Yields Matching Interest Rates
Click here for Spotify / Apple Podcasts
The US 10-year Treasury yield is hovering in the 5% range, and the gap with the S&P 500’s forward earnings yield has narrowed to approximately 0.3 percentage points. The equity risk premium—the additional return required for holding stocks—has effectively vanished when compared to nominal interest rates. On the other hand, when compared to real interest rates, there is a difference of about 2.6 percentage points, and the risk premium calculated back from models remains in the 4% range. The forward P/E ratio is in the 18x range, which is below the 10-year average, and three major Wall Street firms have all set their year-end 2027 targets at 8,700. The decline in the forward P/E ratio is not due to a drop in stock prices but rather a sharp increase in forward EPS, and those earnings are skewed toward AI investments and valuation gains from investments. We will discuss the comparison of stocks and bonds using three metrics, the rise in real interest rates, the sharp increase in forward EPS and the quality of earnings, the differences in assumptions among the three major firms, the stance of fund managers, and comparisons with past periods, to explain the divergence in future developments.
Convergence of Earnings Yield and 10-Year Treasury Yield
The equity risk premium is the additional return that investors in stocks demand over safe assets such as government bonds. A simple way to measure this is to compare the earnings yield with the government bond yield. The earnings yield is the value obtained by dividing earnings per share by the stock price, which is the reciprocal of the P/E ratio.
Stock and Bond Yields (as of November 13)
-
S&P 500 Forward P/E Ratio: 18.3x
-
Forward Earnings Yield: Approx. 5.5%
-
10-Year Treasury Yield: 5.14%
-
Difference: Approx. +0.3 percentage points
According to FactSet’s compilation, the forward P/E ratio of 18.3x is lower than the 5-year average of 19.8x and the 10-year average of 19.1x. Converted to an earnings yield, it is about 5.5%, and the difference from the 10-year Treasury is about 0.3 percentage points. Even when measured by projected earnings, the yield on stocks is at a level only slightly higher than that of government bonds.
In a trailing-based comparison calculated by the author of TheStreet Pro using data from multpl and FRED, the earnings yield was 1.31 percentage points lower than the 10-year Treasury in October. This is the largest negative margin since September 2009, and excluding 2009, when earnings plummeted, it is the largest since July 2002. Lance Roberts of RIA analyzed that at the time of the all-time high in early October, the trailing earnings yield was about 3.7%, and the difference from the 10-year Treasury was about negative 1.6 percentage points. The 10-year Treasury yield hit its highest level since 2002 in early October, hovering around 5.3%.
Risk Premiums Differ Across Three Metrics
The value of the equity risk premium varies significantly depending on the interest rate and type of earnings used for comparison.
Differences Based on Comparison Method
-
Forward Earnings Yield – Nominal 10-Year Treasury: Approx. +0.3 percentage points
-
Trailing Earnings Yield – Nominal 10-Year Treasury: -1.3 to -1.6 percentage points
-
Forward Earnings Yield – Real 10-Year Treasury: Approx. +2.6 percentage points
-
CAPE-based (September) -0.49 points
Compared to nominal interest rates, the equity risk premium is nearly zero or negative. Compared to real interest rates, there is a difference of approximately 2.6 points. While the interest on government bonds remains constant even as inflation progresses, corporate earnings have the characteristic of increasing along with prices. Therefore, there is a school of thought that earnings yields should be compared against real interest rates, which exclude inflation. CAPE is a P/E ratio that uses the average of 10 years of real earnings to smooth out the effects of the business cycle, and comparisons based on this are negative.
Yields on Inflation-Indexed Government Bonds (November 13)
-
10-year TIPS real yield 2.87%
-
Nominal 10-year bond 5.14%
-
Breakeven inflation rate 2.26%
According to TIPSwatch, the 10-year TIPS real yield of 2.87% could reach its highest level since October 2008 at the auction on the 19th. The breakeven inflation rate is the inflation rate priced in by the market, which remains stable at 2.26%.
The third metric is the implied equity risk premium published monthly by Professor Aswath Damodaran of New York University. He calculates the expected return assumed by current stock prices based on future dividend and share buyback forecasts, and determines the difference from government bond yields. The value for November 1st was 4.41%, up from 4.20% the previous month. When using different methods on the same date, the values range from 3.39% to 5.81%. In March, Professor Damodaran explained this indicator as a forward-looking metric that moves to reflect market fear and greed, noting that its nature differs from historical averages.
In its October report, Infrastructure Capital pointed out that expected earnings yields, government bond yields, and model-based risk premiums are figures that answer different questions.
The three figures answer separate questions regarding income, the price of risk, and the expected
comparison between earnings and bonds
The firm states that the fact that the three values have aligned at roughly the same level is a numerical coincidence and does not indicate the same narrative. Depending on which metric is used, US stocks can appear either overvalued or fairly valued.
Real interest rates at the center of rising interest rates
The rise in 10-year bond yields is driven primarily by an increase in real interest rates, not inflation expectations.
Changes in 10-year bonds for 2026 (up to early October)
-
Nominal yield increase 1.06 points
-
Of which real interest rate 0.98 points
-
Of which breakeven 0.08 points
According to Infrastructure Capital’s analysis, over 90% of the rise in nominal yields from the end of 2025 to early October is due to real interest rates. Real interest rates rose from 1.93% to 2.91%, while the breakeven rate saw only a minor change from 2.25% to 2.33%. The market is not wary of accelerating inflation; rather, the price of capital itself, adjusted for inflation, is rising.
Behind the rise in real interest rates is the Federal Reserve’s monetary tightening. The Fed raised interest rates on September 16 for the first time in about three years, lifting the policy rate to 3.75–4.00%. A 0.25-point rate hike is also largely priced in for the December FOMC. According to TheStreet Pro, Goldman Sachs expects two more rate hikes, peaking at 4.25–4.5%, with the first rate cut occurring in December 2027.
When real interest rates rise, the rate at which future earnings are discounted to present value increases, and the theoretical value of stocks decreases. The phenomenon where the risk premium appears to vanish when compared to nominal interest rates is also a result of policies that raise real interest rates.
Decline in forward P/E ratio due to a sharp increase in forward EPS
The decline in the forward P/E ratio is not due to a drop in stock prices. John Butters of FactSet analyzes that the forward P/E ratio as of November 5th fell to 17.7x, the lowest level since November 2023.
Changes from the end of 2025 to November 5th
As stock prices have risen, forward EPS has increased significantly more. Butters states that the main reason for the decline in the forward P/E ratio is the increase in earnings. While 17.7x is below the 5-year and 10-year averages, it is above the 15-year average of 17.6x, the 20-year average of 16.5x, and the 25-year average of 16.4x. Compared to long-term averages, it is not a level that can be called cheap.
By sector, the forward P/E ratio for the IT sector is 17.3x, which is below its 25-year average of 20.0x and its lowest level since March 2020. Energy is also at 11.7x, below its 25-year average.
Earnings performance and outlook (FactSet, November 13)
-
Q3 earnings growth rate 31.9%
-
2026 earnings growth outlook 33.3%
-
2027 earnings growth outlook 16.2%
-
Q3 net profit margin 15.0%
The earnings growth rate for the third quarter has exceeded 25% for three consecutive quarters. 84% of companies reported EPS above expectations, which is higher than the 5-year and 10-year averages. The net profit margin has fallen to 15.0% from the previous quarter’s record high of 17.0%. The earnings growth rate is expected to slow to nearly half in 2027. The aggregate of analysts’ target prices is 9,275, which is 22.2% above the closing price on the 13th.
Earnings skewed toward AI investment and valuation gains on investments
The quality of earnings, which serves as the denominator for earnings yield, influences the assessment of the risk premium. Startup Fortune reported on the 17th on an analysis by Ben Snider of Goldman Sachs.
Impact of AI on Earnings (Goldman Sachs)
-
25% upside from earnings trend
-
Approximately half of the earnings growth in 2026
-
Approximately -5 percentage point contribution to 2028 earnings
AI is boosting S&P 500 earnings by 25% above trend. Approximately half of the earnings growth in 2026 is attributed to AI-related capital expenditures. By 2028, the contribution of capital expenditures to earnings is expected to turn negative, acting as a drag of approximately 5 percentage points.