Bitcoin ETFs Are Bleeding Cash. What IBIT Holders Should Watch Next
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
After iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF (NASDAQ:IBIT) net assets fell to $49.9 billion from $68.7 billion on Oct. 21, investors took out about $2.3 billion from the exchange-traded fund between Nov. 2 and Nov. 17. Across all U.S. spot bitcoin ETFs, net outflows over that period came to about $2.6 billion, with flow data running through Nov. 17.
Someone holding IBIT as a small satellite position near retirement should ask what would show that the selling has finished.
Thus far, the selling has been steady. IBIT had outflows in every session from Oct. 30 through Nov. 17 except one. The exception was Nov. 16, a single $76.5 million inflow day in the middle of the trend.
Bitcoin (CRYPTO:BTC) trades near $63,470, about 50% below its record of $126,080.
How Outflows and Price Drops Each Shrink the Fund
An outflow means investors redeemed shares. Large trading firms hand IBIT shares back to BlackRock (NYSE:BLK | BLK Price Prediction), and the trust gives up the matching bitcoin. A falling price works differently: each share is worth less, but no money leaves the fund. Both reduce net assets.
That explains how the group’s net assets fell from $109 billion to $80 billion even though cumulative inflows since launch still stand at $54 billion. Most of that drop came from price. Redemptions made it worse, and they can push bitcoin lower when the redeemed coins are sold.
A September Rate Hike Is the Macro Factor That Matters Most
The Federal Reserve raised the upper bound of its target rate to 4%[1] from 3.75% on Sept. 16. Bitcoin pays no interest. When cash pays 4% and the Fed is tightening, holding bitcoin means giving up more income than it did when rates were lower. Borrowers who bought it with leverage pull back.
Bitcoin is down 14% over the 60 days since the hike. In 2022, as the Fed raised rates aggressively, bitcoin lost most of its value and steadied only once markets expected an end to the hikes.
To track this, check the CME FedWatch tool weekly and read each Fed policy statement when it comes out. If FedWatch shows traders shifting toward a cut, that is the clearest sign IBIT’s macro headwind is easing. Rising odds of another hike would point to more pressure.
Three Fund Signals That Show Whether Holders Are Giving Up
1. A Real Run of Inflows
One positive day is noise. Three or more inflow days in a row for IBIT would be the first evidence of a change. Daily trackers such as Farside and SoSoValue post flows each evening.
2. IBIT’s Share of Group Assets
IBIT held $49.9 billion of the group’s $79.6 billion on Nov. 17. Its lifetime inflows of $64.1 billion are larger than the whole group’s total, so it has been taking in money that rival funds lost. If IBIT’s assets start falling faster than the group’s, investors are leaving this fund in particular. Its largest disclosed holders at the end of September included hedge funds Brevan Howard and Millennium Management, and hedge funds can exit quickly.
3. Premium or Discount to NAV
Net asset value (NAV) is what the fund’s bitcoin is actually worth per share. IBIT traded at small discounts to NAV on Nov. 2, Nov. 12, and Nov. 13, all well under 1%. If the discount grows and lasts several days, sellers are overwhelming the trading firms that normally keep the price in line with NAV. iShares posts the figure daily on the fund’s page.
What Would Signal the Selling Is Over
Until those signals line up, another day of outflows above $400 million would mean the unwind is still going. That would match the size of the outflows on Nov. 2 and Nov. 6.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.