Caterpillar Fell Nearly 25% Over 3 Months But These Two Wall Street Firms Say It’s Going to Appreciate by Nearly 80%
Caterpillar has shed nearly 40% from its 52-week high while sitting on a backlog that stretches into 2029, and two major Wall Street firms now see a historic opportunity forming in the rubble.
Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT | CAT Price Prediction) is now priced at $647.24, while Wall Street’s average price target sits at $926.91. The difference points to upside of 43.2%.
Caterpillar sells construction and mining equipment, engines and turbines through a global dealer network. Wall Street pays attention because it has become an AI infrastructure supplier. Third-quarter Power Generation sales rose 30% to $3.42 billion on data center demand for turbines and large reciprocating engines.
The most bullish firms see even more upside. HSBC holds a $1,150 target, a level Wells Fargo has also reached. The upside from here works out to 77.7%.
A Quarterly Beat Without a Guidance Raise Sent Caterpillar Sharply Lower
Caterpillar’s selloff dates to a third-quarter report in which the company stuck to its annual sales forecast amid cost pressures. Adjusted EPS of $7.20 exceeded the $7.04 consensus, and revenue of $20.68 billion came in line with estimates. Still, the stock fell 9.25% on the day. That was its sharpest earnings-day drop across nine quarters of reaction data. Investors used to blowouts like the prior quarter’s 31.83% beat got a 2.37% beat.
The losses had started piling up before the report. Shares are down 21.52% over the past month and sit 39.4% below the 52-week high of $1,068.93. That is a drawdown of more than 30% for a Dow blue chip. Management cited tariff-driven manufacturing costs, higher freight, a 70% drop in rail retail sales, higher credit-loss provisions at Cat Financial and yen weakness.
The damage was specific to Caterpillar. In the same session, Deere (NYSE:DE) rose 3.02%, and Cummins (NYSE:CMI) slid 2.55%.
Analysts Are Anchored to a Power Backlog That Runs Into 2029
Visibility supports the optimistic view. On the prior earnings call, backlog reached $72 billion, up 92% year over year, with 59% scheduled for delivery within 12 months. Gas prime power orders extend into the back half of 2028 and into 2029. The chief executive said, “No one is slowing down at the moment.”
Analysts are watching specific catalysts. Caterpillar is resuming a 10-megawatt engine platform, bringing about 1.5 gigawatts of capacity back online with shipments starting in the fourth quarter. Dealer retail sales rose 22% last quarter, Power & Energy retail jumped 36%, and price realization added $663 million.
Analysts are watching specific catalysts. Caterpillar is resuming a 10-megawatt engine platform, bringing about 1.5 gigawatts of capacity back online with shipments starting in the fourth quarter. Dealer retail sales rose 22% last quarter, Power & Energy retail jumped 36%, and price realization added $663 million. (we covered seven other companies feeding the AI data-center expansion, from power to cooling, in a free report here: 7 Stocks Powering the AI Boom)
Estimates keep rising. Consensus 2026 EPS is $27.3294, up from $24.7234 90 days ago, and 2027 sits at $32.5853. That puts the stock at about 20 times 2027 earnings. HSBC’s target also leans on infrastructure spending and growth in high-margin services.
Coverage is split. There are one Strong Buy and 14 Buy ratings, against 11 Holds, one Sell and one Strong Sell. Many targets were also set when the stock traded far higher, so treat them as one data point among many.
Caterpillar Fell Harder Than Deere and Cummins
The peer group held up better than Caterpillar.
Deere trades at $660.03, down 2.78% over the past month and 8.3% below its 52-week high. Its $694.01 target implies just 5.1% upside. Ratings show 5 Strong Buys, 11 Buys, 8 Holds and one Strong Sell. Analysts see far less upside here than in Caterpillar.
Cummins trades at $517.86, roughly flat over the past month but 29.5% below its 52-week high. Its $708.66 target implies 36.8% upside, with 4 Strong Buys, 11 Buys, 8 Holds and no Sells. That upside comes close to Caterpillar’s but still falls short of it.
Caterpillar carries the largest analyst-implied upside in the group. The gap reflects issues specific to Caterpillar, so the question is whether those issues will last.
One Month Nearly Erased Caterpillar’s Lead Over the S&P 500
At $647.24, Caterpillar has 43.2% upside to the $926.91 average target from 28 analysts. The stock is up 13.95% year to date, compared with 12.82% for the S&P 500.
Over one year, Caterpillar gained 11.49%, versus 11.92% for the index. Over the past month, Caterpillar lost 21.52% while the S&P 500 rose 0.68%.
Caterpillar’s Backlog Outweighs Its Cost Problem, but Margins Need Proof
Optimists get a boost if power demand keeps exceeding capacity, the 10-megawatt ramp ships on time and price realization keeps beating tariff costs. That combination would lift margins and close the gap to the consensus target.
The downside risk grows if cost pressure keeps eating into a full order book. Freight, tariffs and credit losses could mean record volumes no longer turn into proportional profit growth. A guidance hold after a run to $1,068.93 suggests the market may have priced in near-flawless execution.
The data leans toward the optimists. At about 20 times 2027 estimates, with backlog visible into 2029, the selloff has outpaced the change in fundamentals. The $1,150 targets need perfect execution, though. The consensus figure is the more realistic measure.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.