Cathie Wood and 10 Other Big Funds Sold Alibaba Last Quarter, While 14 Bought. Who’s Right?
Key Takeaways
-
Of the 460 big funds that have filed 13Fs for the quarter ended Sept. 30, 14 bought Alibaba and 11 sold it, with Cathie Wood’s ARK Invest among the sellers.
-
The buyers bet far more: Viking Global’s new stake of about $478 million was more than four times what all 11 sellers sold, and Hillhouse made Alibaba its No. 2 holding behind PDD Holdings.
-
At 9.6x forward earnings, Alibaba trades well below its 12.9x five-year average, though analysts’ estimates need its earnings to more than double by fiscal 2028.
-
The buyers have the better case, with delivery losses shrinking at both Alibaba and JD.com, but cash burn and new U.S. chip rules mean it will take patience.
Big funds split on Alibaba (BABA:NYSE) last quarter. Of the 460 that have filed 13Fs for the quarter ended Sept. 30, 14 bought it and 11 sold, while 36 held it at the quarter’s end.
Those counts cover funds readers know and any fund with $1 billion or more of US stocks in its 13F, leaving out quant and index funds. A buy is a new position or 20% or more shares added, and a sale is selling out or cutting 20% or more.
The stock is down 25% since Sept. 30, so the sellers look smart for now. But the latest quarters from Alibaba and its delivery rival JD.com (JD:NASDAQ) gave the buyers some support.
The buyers brought much bigger checks
Andreas Halvorsen’s $78.2 billion Viking Global made the biggest buy: a new position of 4.45 million shares, worth about $478 million at quarter-end prices. That’s 1.5% of its 13F stocks, its No. 29 holding: a real stake, but hardly all-in.
Hillhouse’s HHLR Advisors, whose 13F holds $1.54 billion of US stocks, went much further. It took its stake from 183,934 shares to 2.49 million, about $248 million of buying, and Alibaba is now 17.4% of its 13F stocks. Only PDD Holdings (PDD:NASDAQ), at 22.5%, is bigger.
SRS Investment Management opened a $181 million position, and Philippe Laffont’s Coatue started a smaller one of about $33 million. All 14 buyers together put in about $1.1 billion.
TIKR tracks 41 analysts on Alibaba. How many say “Buy”?
See the full breakdown of Buy, Hold, and Sell ratings on Alibaba, along with Wall Street’s revenue and earnings estimates, all in one place. More than 500,000 investors use TIKR to research stocks like this one. See Alibaba’s Analyst Ratings
Cathie Wood all but walked away
Cathie Wood’s ARK Invest cut its stake 96%, from 119,555 shares to 4,691, about $12 million of selling that leaves Alibaba its No. 169 holding. The biggest seller, H&H International Investment, sold all 301,400 of its shares, about $29 million, and Keystone Investors and Contrarius sold about $20 million and $17 million. All 11 sales add up to about $110 million, less than a quarter of Viking’s buy alone.
H&H didn’t leave China e-commerce, though. In the same quarter it added 12% to its PDD stake, now 27.99 million shares worth $2.18 billion and 12.7% of its 13F stocks. PDD is up 7% since Sept. 30. Its September-quarter ad revenue grew 12%, though transaction services, which carry Temu’s fulfillment fees, fell 12% under Europe’s new parcel duty.
Cheap, if the earnings come back
Analysts expect the earnings rebound the buyers are betting on. Alibaba’s normalized EPS fell to RMB 26.80 per ADS in fiscal 2026 (the year to March) from RMB 65.41, and consensus has it back to RMB 61.03 by fiscal 2028, near fiscal 2024’s RMB 62.23:
That’s more than double in two years, and the September quarter showed what’s working and what isn’t. Cloud revenue grew 53%, and the cloud unit’s adjusted EBITA margin rose to 14.5% from 11.6% in June. The e-commerce group’s adjusted EBITA jumped 243%, mainly because quick commerce lost much less. But like-for-like customer management revenue, the merchant fees that pay for everything else, grew just 1% again, and adjusted EPS missed estimates.
JD.com’s quarter points the same way. Its operating margin turned positive at 1.7%, from negative 0.4% a year earlier, and CFO Ian Su Shan credited “meaningful loss reductions” in its new businesses, led by food delivery. With both sides spending less, the subsidy bill that cut Alibaba’s China e-commerce profit 44% in fiscal 2026 should keep shrinking.
Alibaba’s forward P/E shows how little investors are paying for that recovery:
At 9.6x, it’s well below its 12.9x five-year average, not far above its 7.6x low of January 2024. A move back to the average alone would be worth about a third more on today’s estimates.
The consensus target is down about 16% over the past year:
The average target of $162.28 is still double today’s price.
I’m with the buyers
The 25% drop since Sept. 30 (the move from its quarter-end price; nobody knows what each fund paid) has gone the sellers’ way so far. But on TIKR’s numbers, I’m with Viking and Hillhouse. Under 10x earnings, the price already assumes a lot goes wrong, and the September quarter delivered what the recovery needs most: a richer cloud margin and smaller delivery losses.
The risk is cash. Free cash flow was an outflow of RMB 34.47 billion in the September quarter on RMB 50.5 billion of capex, and Goldman Sachs now sees it turning positive only in fiscal 2029. CEO Eddie Wu also said a new U.S. chip license rule could slow cloud growth to 30%-45% next fiscal year.
The December-quarter report, early next year, is the next test: like-for-like customer management revenue growth above 1% and a free cash flow outflow smaller than RMB 34.47 billion would put the buyers on track. The funds’ next 13Fs, due in mid-February, will show who held on.
So what is Alibaba stock actually worth?
TIKR lets you forecast the future price of any stock in less than a minute. Just enter a few assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model and see what Alibaba could be worth. Start from Wall Street consensus estimates, or adjust the inputs to reflect your own view of the business. It’s free to use.