Don’t Let Job Changes Derail Clients’ Retirement Savings
Concerned about an AI bubble? Sign up for The Daily Upside for smart and actionable market news, built for investors.
Have you signed an offer letter recently?
Job changes come in many flavors — not all of them agreeable — but an attractive new gig with a nice bump in pay and an exciting set of responsibilities is a big moment for clients. It’s also a time when their retirement readiness can be put at risk, thanks to a mix of behavioral factors and shortcomings in the design of the 401(k) plan system, said Fiona Greig, global head of public policy and research in Vanguard’s Investment Strategy Group. These include a lack of automatic enrollment policies, low default contribution percentages, friction in the account consolidation process and a natural lack of focus on retirement planning during a major life change.
“Helping savers maintain momentum amid job changes would help more people get and stay on track for retirement,” Greig said. Advisors should check in with their clients soon after they take a new job, she said. “Savers can be doing everything right at one job and then find themselves falling behind again because of plan design defaults.”
Sign up for The Daily Upside at no cost for premium analysis on all your favorite stocks.
READ ALSO: ‘Sister’ to the Rescue: Why SNL’s Sketch Is Ringing True for Retirement Savers and Outdated RMD Info Abounds Online
The Job Changer’s Dilemma
The percentage of 401(k) plans with automatic enrollment has grown meaningfully in recent years, and many new plans are required to use auto-enrollment. It’s still not the norm, however, with about 42% of all plans including the feature, per new Vanguard research. In the company’s own book of business, 61% of plans have auto-enrollment, with 73% of its participants being in such plans. Nationwide, more than two-thirds (69%) of plans with auto-enrollment have default saving rates below 6%.
“That comes out to about 27.7 million workers currently in plans with automatic contribution percentages below 6%,” Greig said. “That’s way too low for achieving retirement security.”
Fidelity suggests that:
-
People should save 15% of their pretax income every year (including matching contributions).
-
The objective should be to save 10 times one’s income by age 67, which is unlikely with a 6% contribution rate.
Of course, job changers can always increase their contributions after enrollment, but it’s easy to forget to do that. Greig wants policymakers to either encourage higher automatic contribution percentages or make saving rates portable, whereby job changers would maintain their prior saving rate or adopt the default saving rate — whichever is higher.
“This way, automatic enrollment when switching jobs would not undo progress,” she said.
Portability Problems. This and related portability issues have caught the eye of the Treasury Department and the IRS, which issued guidance and a related request for comment in August about the establishment of standardized (but still optional) processes and data to facilitate account rollovers between plans.
“Should a significant number of plans adopt the guidance, that could serve as a steppingstone to portable saving rates,” Greig said. “An easy first step might have employers simply communicate the departing worker’s final saving rate as standard off-boarding information.”
This post first appeared on Retirement Upside. To receive actionable insights for financial advisors guiding clients through the strategies, products, and policy shifts shaping retirement outcomes, subscribe to our free Retirement Upside newsletter.