Even if variable interest rates rise, do not rush to refinance. How to judge based on three numbers instead of just “what percentage”
“Interest rates have started to rise, but should I refinance right now?”
I have been receiving this question a lot lately.
Let me give you the conclusion first. Whether or not you should consider refinancing cannot be decided solely by how many percentage points the interest rate has risen. The deciding factors are three numbers: your “remaining loan balance,” “remaining years,” and “various costs associated with refinancing.” Today, I will organize how to look at these from a practical perspective.
When looking at interest rate news, people worry about “how many more percent it can rise before it becomes dangerous.” However, even with the same interest rate increase, there are people for whom refinancing is beneficial and those for whom it is not.
The reason is simple. The effect of refinancing is determined not by the interest rate difference itself, but by “how much the interest rate difference translates into a monetary amount based on your remaining loan balance and remaining years.” The larger the balance and the longer the remaining repayment period, the greater the difference in the total amount even with a small interest rate difference. Conversely, for those with a small balance and only a little time left on their repayment, the amount that can be recovered by refinancing tends to be small even if interest rates rise.
First, check not the interest rate, but the “balance, remaining years, and current applicable interest rate”
These are the three things I always ask about first when consulting on refinancing.
The first is the loan balance. The larger the balance, the greater the difference in the total amount of interest for the same interest rate difference. Conversely, if the balance is small, the amount gained from refinancing tends to be small even if there is an interest rate difference.
The second is the remaining years. The number of years left on the repayment determines the period during which the refinancing effect will be felt. The shorter the remaining years, the less time you have to recover the various costs.
The third is the current applicable interest rate. Please check the interest rate that is actually being applied after subtracting the preferential interest rate, not the base rate. If you make a judgment based on a “feeling that it has gone up” without knowing this, the comparison itself will be off.
Start by checking these three things using your bankbook, repayment schedule, or the bank’s member page.
The profit or loss of refinancing is determined only by “monthly difference × remaining months – various costs”
Think of the profit or loss of refinancing as a simple subtraction.
How much will your monthly repayment amount decrease by switching to a new loan? Multiply that difference by the remaining number of repayment months. Then, subtract the various costs associated with refinancing from that. If the remaining amount is positive, then numerically, refinancing is advantageous.
What is easy to overlook here is the content of the various costs. Items and amounts such as administrative fees, guarantee fees, and registration fees vary depending on the bank and the refinancing destination. Do not judge based only on the “estimated various costs” you saw online; be sure to get a quote from the refinancing destination and check the total amount.
Also, if you are switching to a fixed interest rate, you need to check the interest rate after the fixed period ends. It may look cheap for the first few years, but the total amount may change depending on the interest rate after that. It is important not to decide based solely on the monthly repayment amount in the short term.
Reasons why you cannot be at ease even if the repayment amount does not change—the 5-year rule and the 125% rule
In many cases, variable interest rates have a “5-year rule” and a “125% rule.” This is a mechanism where the repayment amount does not change for 5 years, and even when it is reviewed, it will only rise to 125% of the previous repayment amount.
At first glance, this seems like a reassuring mechanism. However, there is a point to be aware of. During the period when the repayment amount does not change even if interest rates rise, the proportion of interest in the repayment amount increases, and the principal decreases more slowly.
In other words, even if your monthly payments do not change, there is a possibility that your loan is being paid off slower than expected. I recommend checking how the breakdown of principal and interest is changing in your repayment schedule. Note that detailed conditions, such as the handling of unpaid interest, differ depending on the contract details of the lender, so if you are concerned, please check directly with your bank.
Also know the background when a bank says, “Why don’t you switch to a fixed rate?”
When interest rates are rising, banks may approach you asking, “Would you like to switch to a fixed interest rate?” The proposal itself is not necessarily bad. However, please be aware that the other party has their own position. For a bank, switching to a fixed interest rate is a proposal that addresses customer anxiety while simultaneously stabilizing their own revenue.
That is precisely why it is important not to accept the proposal at face value, but to consider it against your own three numbers. Do not judge based on “everyone else is refinancing,” but rather on “what is the case for me?” The optimal answer changes depending on your family’s work situation, future life plans, and plans for early repayment. Instead of looking only at the interest rate figure, choose after organizing “what you must protect and what you can move” in your future life. I believe that is how you make a refinancing decision you won’t regret. As a general rule, you do not need to rush to refinance if your remaining balance is small and the remaining term is short, while you should consider it if the balance is large and the remaining term is long. It is worth checking the numbers once rather than spending your time feeling anxious.
Three questions to ask the bank and what you can check today
Finally, here are three questions you should ask your bank when considering refinancing.
The first is, “What is the total amount of fees required for refinancing?” Please ask for the total amount, not just item by item.
The second is, “What happens to the new interest rate after the fixed period ends?” Whether you choose a fixed or variable rate, make sure to confirm how future interest rates will be determined.
The third is, “What is the ratio of principal to interest in my current repayment amount?” This is a question to help you understand how your repayment is progressing under the 5-year rule and the 125% rule.
What you can do today is first check your remaining balance, remaining term, and current applicable interest rate. Once you know those three things, your vague anxiety about “what if it goes up by X%” will turn into a concrete consideration of “what is the case for me?” Once you have the numbers, try comparing quotes from multiple banks. Being able to judge based on your own numbers, rather than being swayed by interest rate news, is what leads to the greatest peace of mind.