Help Clients Understand Their Retirement Plan, Not Just Trust It
Deric Ned is the Founder and CEO of Ridgemont Capital, where he works with clients on retirement income planning.
Most of my clients arrive having done everything right. They worked with an advisor. They received statements every quarter and filed them away. What they did not receive, in most cases, was a clear answer to the question that actually matters: “How long will this last?”
That is not a failure on their part. It is a feature of how most financial statements are built. They are accurate documents. They are also incomplete ones. And in my experience, the gap between those two things is where most retirement planning problems quietly begin.
What A Statement Can And Cannot Tell Clients
Consider a straightforward example: A client opens the year with $640,000. She withdraws $3,200 a month, which comes to $38,400 across the year. Her statement reports a 6% portfolio return. Her closing balance is $640,000.
Every number on that statement is accurate. The growth and the withdrawals are the same figure, so the balance ends where it began. And yet she now has two facts and no picture. Her balance did not move, which feels like standing still. Her statement reports a 6% gain, which feels like progress. She took out $38,400, which feels like spending. All three are true at once, and nothing in the document tells her which one describes her situation.
Now change one variable. Same client, same withdrawal, different year. Opening balance: $640,000. Withdrawals: $38,400. Portfolio return: -8%. Closing balance: $553,800.
The balance fell $86,200 in 12 months. The withdrawal did not change, but it now represents just under 7% of what remains, against 6% the year before. Same spending, heavier load. Her statement will accurately report all of this. It will not tell her how many years she has left before the math stops working.
That question—”How long will this last?”—is not on the page. It was never going to be on the page.
When Trust Fills The Gap Documentation Leaves
When a plan does not answer the questions a client actually has, trust fills the space instead. That is a reasonable human response. It is also a fragile one.
A financial relationship built on comfort can unravel quickly: one rough quarter, one news segment, one conversation at a dinner party where someone mentions a better return. When that happens, a client who does not understand their plan has no anchor to return to. They may pick up the phone and, under pressure, make a decision they will live with for the next decade.
I’ve found that most advisors are doing honest work inside a system that was not designed to produce complete pictures. Statements are built around compliance requirements, not around the question a 68-year-old woman is actually trying to answer when she opens the envelope.
Making A Plan Complete As Well As Accurate
When a client’s question can only be answered with reassurance rather than numbers, the documentation has more work to do.
Retirement statements are not the only documents with this problem. Any business that hands a client a report, proposal or contract runs the same risk: paperwork that is correct in every detail and still leaves the client unable to answer the question they came in with.
To overcome this in retirement planning, it’s important to show your client how a plan will perform when conditions change, not only when markets cooperate. A projection that runs the same withdrawals through a strong year, a flat year and a bad year can tell your client far more than a single return figure. The same applies to any forecast you share with a client. A forecast that shows only the expected case invites the client to assume nothing will go wrong.
Timing matters, too. Help your client understand what the math looks like with a bad year early in retirement versus a bad year later. In business, a setback in the first months of a project or contract can cost more than one later on, and the same is true with a retirement plan. Your client can plan better if they know that going in.
Cost belongs in the picture, too. What is the total cost of a plan, in dollars, across every account and every year? Just like with any company selling products or services, clients can make better decisions when they can see the full cost in plain numbers instead of piecing it together from separate invoices and line items.
Finally, a retirement plan should not depend solely on the person who built it. If you disappeared tomorrow, could someone else on your team pick up where you left off? That standard protects more than the client. Work that only one person can explain is a continuity risk for the company.
What A Complete Picture Actually Looks Like
A plan that can answer the question a client actually has—”How long will this last?”—starts from income, not from allocation. Make sure the plans you offer map what comes in, what goes out, what the balance looks like across a range of scenarios and where the structural vulnerabilities are before they become crises.
This document should be one your client can hand to a second advisor, a CPA or a trusted family member so they can understand it without a guided tour. That is a reasonable standard. It is also, for many people currently in retirement, a standard their existing documentation does not yet meet.
That is worth knowing before you send the next statement.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?