Mark Warner: Social Security Pay Cap “Unfair.” Next Year, One $250,000 Paycheck Owes $3,577.40 Less Social Security Tax Than Two $125,000 Paychecks
Key Takeaways
-
At a Senate Budget Committee hearing on Nov. 18, Sen. Mark Warner said Social Security’s tax cap isn’t fair. Sen. Ron Wyden and a witness called for eliminating it, but none of these ideas is law.
-
Under today’s law, a single earner making $250,000 next year pays $11,922.60 in Social Security tax, since the 6.2% tax stops at $192,300 of pay.
-
A married couple earning $125,000 each has the same household pay but pays $15,500, or $3,577.40 more. All of their taxed pay counts toward their benefits.
-
Scrapping the cap would raise only the single earner’s bill, to $15,500. Until Congress acts, high earners can plan for the bigger paychecks that come once withholding stops late in the year.
Sen. Mark Warner (D-Va.) took aim at Social Security’s tax cap at a Senate Budget Committee hearing on Nov. 18. “We got to adjust the cap,” he said. “And a cap at $185,000 is, I don’t think fair. It’s not equitable.”
Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) went further at the same hearing and called for “eliminating the cap on Social Security payroll contributions.” Witness Kathryn Anne Edwards, a labor economist and senior fellow at the National Academy of Social Insurance, called for the same thing. Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) posted on X that he’d fix Social Security “by lifting the payroll tax cap,” adding, “I have a bill to get it done.” None of this is law yet. But if you’re paid above the cap, it helps to know what the cap saves you today and what you’d pay without it.
6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields
There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.
Advertisement
Advertisement
But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.
They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.
Same $250,000, a $3,577.40 difference
Under today’s law, workers pay 6.2% of their wages in Social Security tax, and their employers pay another 6.2%. The tax stops at a cap: $184,500 of pay this year and $192,300 next year. (Warner’s $185,000 was this year’s cap, rounded.) Pay above the cap owes no Social Security tax.
Let’s take two hypothetical households with the same $250,000 of pay next year: a single earner, and a married couple who each make $125,000. The single earner pays 6.2% on the first $192,300, or $11,922.60, and nothing on the other $57,700. Each spouse is under the cap, so each pays 6.2% of the full $125,000. That’s $7,750 apiece, or $15,500 for the household.
Advertisement
Advertisement
So the couple pays $3,577.40 more, which is exactly 6.2% of the $57,700 the single earner makes above the cap. The two households’ employers pay a matching 6.2%, so the same gap shows up again on the employers’ side.
No extra benefit above the cap
The single earner’s break has a catch. The cap is also the most pay Social Security counts toward benefits, so that $57,700 adds nothing to her record. Every dollar the couple earns goes on their own records, which means all of the tax they pay is on pay that counts toward their benefits.
To see where the ceiling sits, take SSA’s example of a worker who earned the taxable maximum every year from age 22 and retires at 67 in January 2027. That worker gets $4,188 a month, the most Social Security pays at 67 next year, no matter how far above the cap their pay went.
Scrapping the cap would change only one of these bills
Wyden, Edwards and Gallego all want the cap gone. Here’s what that would mean next year for these two households and a third hypothetical worker earning $90,000:
Advertisement
Advertisement
With no cap, the single earner would pay 6.2% of all $250,000, or $15,500, the same as the couple. The couple’s bill wouldn’t change, and neither would the $90,000 earner’s $5,580, since all of their pay is already taxed. Only people paid above the cap would pay more. In her written testimony, Edwards said 6% to 8% of earners are in that group in any given year.
Warner didn’t commit to removing the cap. He said there are “a variety of ways” to raise it, including one that leaves a gap for some higher pay before the tax applies again above $1 million. Under that kind of plan, what a $250,000 earner owes would depend on where the bill draws its lines. Whether the extra tax would earn extra benefits also depends on the bill. Edwards, who supports eliminating the cap, wrote that she thinks benefits should reflect the added contributions, and that the benefit formula could be adjusted so lower earners still get a bigger share of their pay back.
What you can do under today’s law
Say you’re paid like the single earner: $250,000 a year, in equal checks every two weeks. Your Social Security withholding stops after the 20th paycheck of 2027, once your pay passes $192,300. Each of your last six paychecks of the year is then about $596 bigger, so it’s worth deciding ahead of time where that money goes.
If you changed jobs in 2026, check your W-2s when they arrive. Each employer withholds 6.2% on the pay it gives you. If your wages from two employers add up to more than this year’s $184,500, together they may have withheld more than the most anyone owes, which is 6.2% of $184,500, or $11,439. You can claim the extra back on your 2026 tax return as a credit against income tax. A married couple works this out separately for each spouse, so the couple at $125,000 apiece has nothing to claim. If one employer alone withheld too much, the credit doesn’t apply.
Advertisement
Advertisement
The way I see it, if your pay runs past the cap, those bigger paychecks late in the year should go straight to savings. They’re exactly the slice of pay Wyden, Edwards and Gallego want taxed, so I wouldn’t build a monthly budget around them. The $192,300 cap for next year is already set, and only a bill passed by Congress would change it. If one moves forward, its text will show us where the tax stops and whether the extra tax comes with extra benefits.
Enjoy your retirement in style with these safe 6%+ dividend yields
Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.
Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.
Advertisement
Advertisement
We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now.