Stock market selloff: Should long-term investors buy the dip or wait?
Key takeaways:
- History offers reassurance: Major market downturns have been followed by recoveries, although some have taken years.
- Not every dip is worth buying: Focus on companies with sustainable earnings, strong balance sheets and reasonable valuations.
- You don’t need to time the bottom: Dollar-cost averaging can help investors put money to work gradually while managing the risk of further declines.
What history tells us about buying during market downturns
When markets fall sharply, the natural instinct is to wait until the uncertainty clears. But history suggests that some of the best long-term investment opportunities have emerged when investor confidence was weakest.
Consider the major US stock market downturns of the past 25 years:
|
Market downturn |
S&P 500 decline |
Recovery to previous high |
|
Dot-com crash (2000–2002) |
~49% |
May 2007 |
|
Global financial crisis (2007–2009) |
~57% |
March 2013 |
|
COVID-19 crash (2020) |
~34% |
August 2020 |
|
Inflation and rate shock (2022) |
~25% |
January 2024 |
Source: Historical S&P 500 price-index data. Approximate peak-to-trough declines based on closing prices, excluding dividends. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns.
The lesson is not that markets recover quickly. Some recoveries take months, others take years.
But markets also tend to rebound before the economic news becomes reassuring. US stocks bottomed in March 2009 while the economy was still in recession. In 2020, equities recovered even as the pandemic continued to disrupt economic activity.
Waiting until everything feels safe can mean missing an important part of the recovery.
That said, not every investment recovers. The Nasdaq took around 15 years to regain its dot-com peak, while many individual technology stocks never recovered. This makes diversification and investment quality particularly important.
Is the current market selloff a buying opportunity?
Today’s selloff reflects genuine concerns about AI valuations, financing risks, higher bond yields and the sustainability of earnings growth.
The AI investment cycle remains a powerful structural theme, but investors are questioning how quickly companies can translate massive spending into sustainable profits.
We see the AI cycle evolving from chips and infrastructure towards adoption and productivity. This transition could create new winners, but also expose weaker business models.
For long-term investors, the opportunity may therefore be broader than simply buying beaten-down AI stocks. Quality companies across healthcare, industrials, financials and other sectors may offer exposure to different earnings drivers at more attractive valuations.
The goal is not to buy whatever has fallen the most, but to identify sustainable earnings and long-term growth at reasonable prices.
Further downside remains possible, particularly if interest rates stay elevated, AI monetisation disappoints or corporate earnings weaken.
Dollar-cost averaging: Why you don’t need to predict the bottom
One of the biggest challenges during a market selloff is deciding when to invest.
Buy too early, and markets could fall further. Wait too long, and the recovery may already be underway.
This is where dollar-cost averaging (DCA) can help.
DCA involves investing a fixed amount at regular intervals, regardless of market conditions. When prices fall, the same contribution buys more units. When prices rise, it buys fewer.
How DCA works: A simple example
Imagine investing $500 every month into an ETF.
|
Month |
ETF price |
Units bought |
|
January |
$10 |
50.0 |
|
February |
$8 |
62.5 |
|
March |
$5 |
100.0 |
|
April |
$8 |
62.5 |
|
May |
$10 |
50.0 |
|
Total |
325 units |
After investing $2,500, the investor owns 325 units at an average cost of approximately $7.69 per unit, despite the ETF starting and ending at $10.
At the final $10 price, those holdings would be worth $3,250.
Illustrative example only. Excludes transaction costs and assumes a price recovery. Actual investments may continue declining and can result in losses.
DCA does not guarantee better returns than investing a lump sum. In fact, Vanguard research suggests lump-sum investing has historically outperformed phased investing roughly two-thirds of the time, because markets tend to rise over the long term.
But DCA offers something valuable: discipline. It reduces the pressure to make a single market-timing decision and can help investors remain consistent through volatile periods.
Regular ETF investments, including through automated investment plans, can make this approach easier to maintain.
How should long-term investors approach the selloff?
Rather than trying to predict the next market move, investors can focus on three practical steps:
- Review portfolio concentration. Investors heavily exposed to US technology or AI may benefit from diversifying across sectors, geographies and asset classes.
- Invest gradually where appropriate. Regular contributions or phased investments can reduce the impact of an unfortunate entry point, although they do not eliminate market risk.
- Match investments to time horizons. Money needed for near-term expenses should remain separate from capital intended for long-term growth.
Investors should also maintain sufficient liquidity and remember that bonds, gold and other diversifiers can behave differently across market environments.
The bottom line: Think beyond the next few weeks
Bear markets are uncomfortable because losses are visible today, while the potential rewards remain uncertain.
Yet history reminds us that periods of market stress can create attractive entry points for investors who have time, diversification and a disciplined plan on their side.
The current selloff may not be over, and not every beaten-down stock will recover. But that does not mean long-term investors need to remain on the sidelines.
The opportunity is not necessarily to catch the market bottom. It is to use lower prices, regular investing and thoughtful diversification to build a stronger portfolio for the next cycle.