The Stock Market’s Biggest Risk Isn’t a Crash. It’s What Investors Might Do When One Arrives.
Imagine seeing your nest egg lose 30% of its value. In this scenario, the market has already delivered a painful setback. Selling may seem like the obvious way to regain control, but selling also creates a new problem: When will you get back into the market?
In reality, panic selling — and delaying reentering the market — can lead to enormous opportunity costs for investors. Let’s explore why.
Image source: Getty Images.
Selling creates a new problem
Seeing your portfolio lose value is never fun. Indeed, psychological studies have shown that investment losses have a greater psychological impact than equivalent gains, a phenomenon known as loss aversion. Therefore, it’s completely understandable that many people seek immediate relief when the market enters a sell-off, correction, or crash.
However, the psychological relief of liquidating investments creates a new problem: determining when “it’s safe.”
In practice, most investors simply wait too long. Many wait for recessions to end or for bullish headlines to appear. But bullish headlines often lag positive price action. As a result, investors on the sidelines often miss out on massive recovery rallies. As we’ll see next, that can have a significant impact on long-term growth.
The recovery math is less forgiving than it looks
Consider a $10,000 portfolio. If it drops 30%, its value will fall to $7,000. To get back to $10,000, the portfolio will need to gain $3,000. Since the overall value has fallen, it will need to generate approximately a 43% return on $7,000 to reach $10,000. So to wipe out a 30% drop, it needs to gain 43%. These amounts differ because the starting amounts differ.
Beyond the arithmetic, there are other costs. Transaction costs, lost dividend payments, and taxes have to be considered. In short, selling might ease one type of headache but create several others.
A falling stock price doesn’t automatically equal a broken business
Despite understanding the math and the other implications of selling, many investors can’t resist the urge to sell when the stock market is falling. One way to train yourself not to sell is to imagine a similar situation in a different market.
For example, let’s say you own a house. Now imagine that another house in your neighborhood sells for half of what might normally be expected. That sale will decrease the value of all homes in the neighborhood, perhaps significantly. But even if the price of your own home falls 10%, 15%, or even 25%, that doesn’t mean one of the bedrooms in your home disappears.
Stock portfolios work the same way. Prices can fall, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that the businesses behind the stocks have deteriorated to the same degree.
Patience works best when the portfolio is built for it
For a buy-and-hold strategy to work, investors must build a portfolio that can withstand periods of volatility. Leveraged positions and meme stocks can wreck a portfolio during a stock market correction or crash. Therefore, savvy investors know to limit their exposure, or, better yet, avoid such investments altogether. By building a diversified portfolio based around well-run businesses, an investor can avoid much of the worst effects of a market downturn.
What to do when a crash arrives
Market crashes are terrible, but thankfully, they’re also rare. However, to prepare for them, it’s best to have a plan. Writing it down can help you manage your emotions, think carefully, and avoid panic. At the end of the day, the math and the studies are clear: It’s best to ride out market downturns rather than sell and try to time reentry perfectly.
If you can keep a cool head and remember this in the moment, you’ll likely come through the next financial downturn in better shape than many other investors.
Where to invest $1,000 right now
When our analyst team has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, Stock Advisor’s total average return is 823%* — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 209% for the S&P 500.
They just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now, available when you join Stock Advisor.
*Stock Advisor returns as of November 16, 2026.