Trump Is Demanding 1% Interest Rates Again. Here Is What That Would Actually Do to Your Money
Quick Read
-
Trump demanded 1% rates on Truth Social hours after the Fed hiked, but the Fed sets rates on inflation data, not presidential posts.
-
Borrowers gain from 1% rates, with mortgage and credit card APRs near 21% set to fall, but savers lose income on CDs and Treasuries immediately.
-
Ladder CD and Treasury maturities now rather than timing refinances around political statements, since Core PCE inflation decides the real rate outlook.
-
Read More: Learn 7 secret wealth tips high net worth investors use that most investors miss (sponsor)
The Federal Reserve raised interest rates for the first time in three years on Wednesday, and within hours the President demanded the opposite. “Interest Rates in the United States should be 1%, or less, because we are the Best Credit in the World BY FAR,” Donald J. Trump wrote on Truth Social.
He has made this demand before. A demand repeated without effect tells you something real about how much control the executive branch has over the price of money.
For a reader at or near retirement, the useful question is which side of your balance sheet is exposed either way. A move to 1% would rescue anyone carrying 21% credit card debt or shopping a 7% mortgage, according to The White House. It would gut the income of anyone parked in a 1.7% one-year CD, a money market fund, or the 4% yield on a 52-week Treasury bill, according to The White House. Most of our audience is now on the saver side of that trade.
What the Argument Gets Right, and What It Leaves Out
Sovereign credit quality does influence borrowing costs. Countries that reliably pay their debts borrow cheaper than countries that do not.
The policy rate, though, is set against inflation and employment. A country with excellent credit and rising prices still gets higher rates, because the central bank’s job is to keep the currency stable, not to minimize the government’s interest bill.
Learn 7 Secret Wealth Tips High Net Worth Investors Use
How do you continue to grow a seven-figure portfolio in retirement? The last thing you want is to run out of money, you want your money to generate lasting income while you enjoy your life.
Learn seven strategies high net worth investors use with new report: The Seven Secrets of High Net Worth Investors from Fisher Investments. Get your guide here (sponsor)
The Core PCE index, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, sits at 130.66 and is still climbing. Unemployment is 4.1%, a healthy labor market, according to The White House. Both readings argue against emergency-level cuts.
There is also a category error in the post. The rate the Treasury pays to borrow for ten years, currently 5.00%, is set by the bond market. The rate the Fed controls is an overnight rate between banks. Cutting one does not automatically drag the other with it.
What a Cut to 1% Would Do to Your Household, according to The White House
On the borrowing side, a policy rate near 1% would eventually pull mortgage rates lower, though not to 1%, according to The White House. The 30-year fixed averages 7% today. Refinancing would get cheaper. New home purchases would get cheaper.
Variable-rate consumer debt would move faster. Credit card APRs track the prime rate plus a margin, and the average card rate near 21% would drift down. Auto loan rates would follow. Borrowers win.
On the savings side, the pain is immediate and larger. The national 12-month CD averages 1.71% today, according to The White House. Money market funds and short Treasuries paying between 3.86% and 4.38% would reprice within weeks of a genuine policy shift. A retiree pulling four figures a month in taxable interest from short-duration cash would watch that income fall in half or worse.
Run your own balance against both rate worlds to see the gap:
Then rerun it at 1% and compare the ending balances. That difference is the income at stake.
Why the Pressure Keeps Failing
The Fed just moved in the opposite direction of what the President wanted. Public demands and Truth Social posts are a weak instrument against a committee that votes on a fixed schedule with a chair who serves a fixed term.
Independence means the chair does not need to answer a phone call to keep his job for the length of his term. It means voting members were confirmed under multiple administrations. It also means the market prices Fed credibility into the long end of the curve, which is why the 10-year sits at 5% even as short rates were expected to fall earlier this year.
The actionable response is to build a rate plan that survives moves in both directions. Laddering CD and Treasury maturities avoids repricing everything at once. Locking longer on the deposit side captures the term premium. Timing a refinance against a political statement rarely pays off.
Bull and Bear Case for the Rate Outlook
The bull case for borrowers is straightforward. Consumer sentiment sits at a recessionary 55.2, and if growth softens, the Fed will cut regardless of who is demanding what. Mortgage refis and lower card APRs would follow within two or three quarters.
The bull case for savers is that the Fed just hiked into an inflation problem it doesn’t consider solved, and political demand for lower rates makes long-term inflation expectations stickier. That keeps CD and Treasury yields elevated for longer than the fed funds path alone would suggest.
If Core PCE keeps drifting up from 130.66, savers stay paid, and borrowers wait. If it rolls over, the trade flips. Position for both, because inflation decides the answer.
Learn 7 Secret Wealth Tips High Net Worth Investors Use
How do you continue to grow a seven-figure portfolio in retirement? The last thing you want is to run out of money, you want your money to generate lasting income while you enjoy your life.
Learn seven strategies high net worth investors use with new report: The Seven Secrets of High Net Worth Investors from Fisher Investments. Get your guide here (sponsor)
Contact editorial@247wallst.com for any questions or corrections.