Trump Trade Deal Could Leave $3.5 Billion Hole in Canada’s Budget
Canada could lose 5 billion Canadian dollars ($3.5 billion) in expected tariff revenue if its trade war with President Donald Trump ends earlier than anticipated, potentially putting Prime Minister Mark Carney’s budget targets at risk, according to a new parliamentary report.
Canada’s independent Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) warned Tuesday that Ottawa’s latest budget assumes retaliatory tariffs on American goods will remain in place into the 2027-28 financial year.
Ending them sooner would reduce customs revenue by approximately C$5 billion, although the watchdog has not established that the entire amount would translate into a higher budget deficit, even as Washington and Ottawa continue negotiations over a possible trade agreement.
Read More on News
The finding presents an unexpected complication for Carney as he seeks relief from Trump’s tariffs on Canadian exports.
However, a trade agreement would not necessarily mean all Canadian retaliatory tariffs are removed immediately, and the PBO has not calculated whether the wider economic benefits of ending the dispute could offset the lost revenue.
Carney has insisted that any agreement must protect Canada’s automotive industry, which has been hit by Trump’s tariffs.
He has also warned that Canada could pursue alternative investment from Chinese, European and Japanese automakers if Washington refuses to reach acceptable terms.
Meanwhile, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent expressed optimism last week about reaching agreements with Canada and Mexico.
U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer has also confirmed that negotiations are continuing, although Washington has not committed to a deadline for reaching an agreement.
Budget Deficit
The watchdog also revealed that Carney’s government has just C$2 billion of room before missing its target of reducing the deficit relative to the size of the economy in 2027-28, less than half the potential customs revenue shortfall identified in the report.
That target requires Canada’s annual deficit to be smaller relative to the country’s overall economy. The PBO found that the Canadian government has little room for unexpected costs or weaker revenues before missing it.
The PBO warned that the government’s own downside economic scenario would already breach that target, adding C$3.6 billion to the projected deficit in 2027-28.
Despite these concerns, the watchdog said the government’s budget was currently projected to meet both of its fiscal targets, although the margin for unexpected economic setbacks was narrow.
Carney unveiled his latest budget earlier this month with Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne, titled “Masters of our Destiny,” promising to strengthen Canada’s economy, protect jobs, and invest in major projects.
The government expects to spend C$62.3 billion more than it collects in 2026-27, with another C$62.5 billion deficit forecast the following year.
A deficit means Ottawa must borrow money to cover the gap between its spending and revenue.
The budget also forecasts customs revenue of C$11.1 billion in 2026-27, reflecting the money collected from import duties, including Canadian counter-tariffs. This covers customs duties generally, rather than revenue from retaliatory tariffs alone.
The government expects those receipts to help finance its spending plans while it works toward reducing its annual deficit.
The PBO also found that Ottawa had introduced C$151.5 billion in additional spending measures over five years compared with its spring financial update. The government used almost all the extra financial room created by stronger revenue and spending forecasts, leaving its projected deficits largely unchanged.
Across the three spending plans introduced under Carney, the watchdog calculated that new government measures total C$331.6 billion. Of that, C$201.7 billion, or 61 percent, was classified by the PBO as operating spending rather than capital investment.
The government’s financial outlook had improved since the spring, helped by stronger-than-expected economic results and higher global oil prices. However, the PBO found that Ottawa had committed 96 percent of its additional financial room to new measures rather than significantly reducing its deficit.
“The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more,” Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan said.
John Fragos, Champagne’s spokesperson, defended the government’s spending plans, saying that around C$90 billion, instead of the latest budget’s C$150 billion in new measures, was directed toward capital investment.
He said that the government’s additional borrowing was intended to support future economic growth and attract investment.
Fragos also pointed to the government’s commitments to balance its operating budget and reduce the deficit relative to the size of the economy.
The watchdog also challenged how Ottawa classifies investment spending. It warned that under the international System of National Accounts definition, the government’s operating budget would remain in deficit throughout the forecast period, rather than reaching balance as Ottawa projects under its own accounting framework.
The budget also sets aside C$11.5 billion to help Canadian workers and businesses affected by the trade dispute.
Around C$6.1 billion is directed toward Ontario’s steel and automotive industries and critical minerals supply chains. However, the watchdog questioned whether enough support was available for other affected provinces.
Helping Canadian Workers
The PBO also identified separate assistance worth C$2.2 billion for the forestry industry, which has faced pressure from American trade restrictions. That support is expected to benefit businesses in British Columbia, Ontario and Quebec.
Another C$3.5 billion is earmarked for temporary employment insurance measures, helping workers who lose their jobs or face reduced hours.
The watchdog noted that the employment insurance measures are available to workers across Canada, not only those directly affected by American tariffs. It also warned that their costs could eventually contribute to higher insurance premiums.
Carney’s government says its budget will strengthen Canada’s finances over time, with the deficit gradually shrinking compared with the size of the economy.
But the PBO warned that the government’s borrowing plans leave it exposed to unexpected economic setbacks, particularly as interest payments on federal debt continue to rise.
However, the watchdog concluded that Canada’s current federal fiscal policy remains sustainable over the longer term, with government debt projected to decline relative to the size of the economy.
Ryan warned that interest payments on Canada’s debt are now the fastest-growing major federal expense. Public debt charges are projected to increase from C$60.2 billion in 2026-27 to C$85.5 billion by 2030-31, growing by an average of 9.8 percent annually over the five years beginning in 2025-26.
The watchdog estimates Ottawa’s net borrowing requirements will total approximately C$765 billion over the next five years, partly to finance major investments and other government activities.
“It’s important to look beyond deficits and consider actual cash borrowing,” Ryan said in a statement. “This budget forecasts three-quarters of a trillion dollars in new borrowing over five years. That’s a significant increase to taxpayers’ debt financing load, just as interest rates are starting to climb.”
That compares with C$289 billion in projected budget deficits over the same period.
The difference reflects borrowing to finance loans, investments and other financial transactions that require cash but are not fully counted as expenses in the annual deficit. Some of these transactions create financial assets for the government.
The PBO warned that the government’s fiscal targets do not directly restrict this additional borrowing, meaning Ottawa could meet its deficit targets while still taking on substantially more debt.
Interest Payments Climb
The watchdog warned that rising debt-servicing costs could put additional pressure on government finances, particularly if interest rates increase.
The PBO also questioned whether the government’s staffing figures provide a complete picture of its planned workforce reductions. Ottawa expects to reduce public service staffing to around 330,000 by 2028-29, but the PBO said those figures exclude employees at Crown corporations, which are taking on a growing role in delivering Carney’s economic plans.
Despite its warnings, the PBO concluded that Canada’s federal finances remain sustainable over the longer term because government debt is projected to decline relative to the size of the economy. However, it cautioned that its assessment did not account for Canada’s pledge to increase defense spending to 5 percent of GDP by 2035.
Ending the tariff dispute between Ottawa and Washington could also benefit Canada’s economy by lowering costs for businesses and consumers, and encouraging investment.
The PBO has previously estimated that prolonged trade restrictions could leave Canada’s economy 1.4 percent smaller after five years than it would otherwise have been.
The watchdog has not determined whether those wider economic benefits would offset the potential loss of tariff revenue.
Champagne defended the government’s economic strategy when unveiling the budget on November 5, warning that decades of international trade stability were being overturned.
“The global trading system that brought stability for decades is being rewritten,” he told the House of Commons of Canada, adding that uncertainty was leaving Canadians worried about their jobs, businesses, and ability to afford everyday life.
Champagne insisted Canada had the resources and economic strength to withstand the disruption. “Nostalgia is not a strategy,” he said, quoting Carney.
He also pointed to forecasts suggesting Canada would have the second-fastest-growing economy in the G7 in 2027.
Speaking ahead of the budget, Champagne said Canada’s economic plans would continue regardless of the outcome of negotiations with Washington.
“Whatever may happen in these discussions [around Canada-U.S. trade], we will see,” he said. “But one thing is true: everything I just said is what we need to do for ourselves.”
Contact Newsweek editors for this story: Robert Greenall, Daniel Orton, Gray R. Thomas