EU reset threatens trade war with Britain’s allies
The EU reset threatens a trade war with Britain’s allies, Andy Burnham has been warned.
Shanker Singham, a former government trade advisor, said countries including the US, India, Australia and New Zealand could retaliate against the UK for undermining the terms of their agreements that were approved after Brexit.
Under Mr Burnham’s deal, Britain has agreed to align with the Sanitary and Phytosanitary agreement (SPS), the bloc’s food and drink safety rules, and link to the EU’s emissions trading standard.
Both agreements come at a cost to British sovereignty, as they will see the UK become an EU rule-taker, changing its laws to match those of Brussels without having any real say in their drafting.
Mr Singham, who worked as an advisor on trade in Theresa May’s administration, said that if the UK is “no longer in control of its own regulatory environment”, then it “cannot honour the terms” of trade deals it has struck with international partners.
He added that Mr Burnham’s EU deal risks retaliation in “big chunks of the economy”, while the US could retaliate with tariffs.
One example he gave was the US could withdraw the generous reduction in car export tariffs it agreed with the UK under a trade agreement last year, which would be enough to “bring Jaguar Land Rover to its knees”, according to Mr Singham.
Mr Singham, who previously advised the US government on trade for six years during Barack Obama’s presidency, told The Telegraph: “The US could very well retaliate. They are certainly very unhappy about it. They were particularly upset about the fact that they announced the deal with the UK about 24 hours before the UK announced its new alignment with the EU.”
Labour MPs have also raised concerns about the impact the EU reset deal may have on Britain’s global trading relationships.
One backbencher said: “It could scupper hopes of extending the deals we’ve got with the growing economies around the Pacific Ocean. They are much bigger economies, more successful economies.
“The EU is a basket case. It’s over regulated. It’s not got a single major tech company because of the way it regulates tech companies.
“We are better off, in the long term, trading with the rest of the world and not the EU, which is the slowest-growing continental economy in the world.”
Advertisement
Jamieson Greer, the US trade representative, said in September that the UK’s closer alignment with the EU poses a “problem” and a “challenge” for trade deals with Washington.
In an interview with the Financial Times, he said: “Within a few days of signing our deal last year, they signed a dynamic alignment agreement with the EU, essentially saying, you know, whatever you guys decide on some of your regulations and standards, et cetera, we’re going to follow.
“That’s how we interpret it, at least, and we interpreted that based on my conversations with the UK, where I say, hey, you’re free of the EU, why don’t you liberalise a little bit, accept goods made to American standards, accept agricultural goods made to American standards?
“And when they say, well, we have to wait and see what the EU says about it, you know, that is a problem for us, and that’s challenging.”
Mr Singham said that Britain’s global allies would feel undermined by the EU deal, explaining: “They will say ‘we did a deal with you on the basis that you have control over your own regulatory environment’.
“If we are not in control of our regulations, we can’t really say, ‘well you have to talk to Brussels…’ That will go down exceptionally badly with our CPTPP (Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership) partners.”
Mr Singham said the international trade community viewed the EU’s food and drink regulations in particular as a “global outlier”, adding: “It has unified the whole world in complaining about it – in the Gulf, India, America, Canada – it is known in the world as the most restrictive precautionary regime out there.
“The point is that the other countries will see the UK being part of the SPS zone as a massive dagger aimed at their agricultural export interests. They will react accordingly.”
Mr Singham, who is now chief executive of Competere, a trade law and economic policy consultancy, and also chairs the Growth Commission, said the British Government faced a stark choice: “Drop the EU reset or face trade sanctions from these other countries.”
Gerard Lyons, an economist and research fellow at the Centre for Policy Studies, said that moving closer to the EU on the single market “ties your hands globally”.
He said: “It’s all about trade-offs – if you accept something on one side there is a trade off on another side. The UK has capitulated at every stage. The trade off was very skewed.”
A government spokesman said: “These claims are wrong. This deal is fully consistent with our international obligations, keeps our freedom to strike trade deals around the world, and cuts red tape and costs for British businesses.”