Why I leave profit-taking to 'trailing stop-loss orders' in Japanese stock swing trading
Hello, this is Yassun.
Last time, I wrote about how much of a loss I allow per trade. This time, it’s about profit-taking, or in other words, where to sell when you have a profit.
Conclusion: Do not decide where to take profits
When I buy, I don’t set a target price like ‘sell when it reaches this amount’.
Instead, I gradually raise my stop-loss order and let it sell automatically when the upward trend breaks. This method is called trailing (trailing stop).
Why I don’t set a target price
I decide that my stop-loss will be up to 1.5% of my swing trading capital per trade. There is an upper limit to the size of a loss.
On the other hand, if you put an upper limit on the size of a win, you will miss out on the growth when you catch a stock that rises significantly.
I believe that swing trading performance is often supported by the occasional big win. Losses are kept small, and wins are left with room to grow. For that reason, I don’t decide where to take profits, but leave it to the market.
In particular, stocks bought after breaking through a high can enter a ‘blue sky’ state where there is no one above wanting to sell. If I had set a target price, I would have gotten off there.
How to trail
The method is simple.
-
When the stock price rises and a new swing low (the low after rising and falling slightly) is formed
-
Raise the stop-loss order to slightly below that swing low
-
Stop-loss orders can be raised, but never lowered
As I wrote before, I follow Dow Theory, viewing that ‘as long as highs and lows are rising, the uptrend continues.’ If it breaks the swing low, it’s a sign that the upward trend has broken. Using the same logic as a stop-loss, I decide on profit-taking based on whether the upward trend has broken.
Do not raise the stop-loss while the 25-day moving average slope is weak
There is one detailed rule.
In the first place, I do not enter new positions in stocks where the 25-day moving average is flat. This is because stocks without upward momentum are not the type I target.
While holding a position, if the slope of the 25-day line becomes weak, I do not raise the stop-loss even if a swing low is formed.
When the slope is weak, the upward momentum has faded, and the stock is in a state close to consolidation. During this time, the swing lows that form are often shallow, and if you raise your stop-loss to those levels, it becomes easy to get stopped out by minor fluctuations. I wait until the 25-day moving average is firmly pointing upward again and the upward trend is clearly defined before raising the stop-loss.
Do nothing special before events
Even before major events like the FOMC or US inflation data, I do not go out of my way to raise my stop-loss. I let the event pass with the stop-loss set based on the chart pattern.
However, as I wrote in a previous article, if I have a small unrealized gain in a highly volatile stock, I may manually close the position before an economic indicator is released. Also, since I do not hold positions through earnings announcements, I close them before the announcement.
Weaknesses of this method
-
Cannot sell at the top: Since I sell only after the price returns to a swing low, the price will inevitably be slightly lower than the absolute peak.
-
May give back some profits: The larger the unrealized gain, the larger the amount that will be lost before the position is sold.
-
If consolidation lasts a long time, it is hard to reach a conclusion: During periods where the price neither rises nor falls, capital remains tied up.
There is a market saying, ‘Leave the head and the tail for others.’ I do not aim to sell at the top from the start, and I prioritize capturing the middle of the upward move.
Summary
-
Do not set a profit-taking point (target price).
-
Every time a swing low forms, raise the stop-loss to just below it (trailing). Do not lower it.
-
If the upward trend breaks, profit is taken automatically.
-
Do not raise the stop-loss while the 25-day moving average slope is weak.
-
You cannot sell at the top. Prioritize capturing the middle of the move.
Next time…
Why I chose the S&P 500 instead of All Country for long-term investment
Returning to the topic of long-term investment. I will write about why I chose the S&P 500 instead of the commonly compared All Country (eMAXIS Slim All Country) as my long-term investment destination.
I would be happy if you could follow me.
I have also written an article that summarizes all the rules for Japanese stock swing trading, from how to select stocks to calculating position sizes and actual trade examples. I have also included a trading log template.
※Disclaimer
This article introduces the author’s personal thoughts and investment policy. It does not recommend the purchase of specific financial products or the timing of trades. Please make your own investment decisions.