Will Nike’s New CFO Reset Expectations Amid Wall Street Scrutiny?

Wall Street might be debating how long a Nike Inc. turnaround could take. But the one thing they seem to agree on is the expectation of a fiscal year 2027 reset, now that a new monetary chief is steering the financial ship.

“A new CFO owns none of the prior guidance,” Jefferies analyst Randal Konik said on Monday, noting that expectations are low prior to the first quarter report on Thursday. Konik, who has a “buy” rating on shares of Nike, said that investors have heard the strategy and now what they need are the numbers. That’s why he said that the upcoming investor day is the more important event, not the first quarter report. Nike is holding its investor day on Nov. 16 and 17.

More from WWD

Nike disclosed in June that David Denton would join the sportswear and footwear giant on Aug. 17 as chief financial officer, succeeding Matthew Friend. At the time, Wall Street saw the executive change as a strategic move, one that was the result of a measured turnaround that is progressing in deliberate fashion.

Analysts also expected that the arrival of a new financial sheriff would likely mean more conservative guidance ahead. That’s because Nike issued a statement that said Denton’s focus will be to “support disciplined execution, capital allocation and long-term value creation.” And they began speculating that a more conservative guidance would imply that the turnaround under chief executive officer Elliott Hill’s watch will take more time than first thought.

While Hill’s focus on running has paid off, the rest of the business has been uneven, with China one of the biggest challenges.

Kelly Crago, who recently joined the equity research team at BMO, said that Nike is attempting a complex global turnaround at what she described as a “tricky time,” with lifestyle demand slowing and competition heating up.

Cristina Fernández of Telsey Advisory Group (TAG) noted that Nike lowered sales guidance through the second quarter of fiscal 2027 when the company posted fourth quarter fiscal 2026 results in June. In addition, she noted second quarter 2026 results from both JD Sports and Dick’s Sporting Goods and Foot Locker that indicated that demand for athletic footwear weakened during the summer months in both the U.S. and Europe, citing to pressure on legacy lifestyle shoes.

Based on these two factoids, the analyst said that it is “possible new CFO David Denton further moderates expectations for second quarter fiscal 2027.” She also forecasted earnings per share for the period to be $1.60, down from $1.70, due to a contraction of sales and operating margin contraction.

Fernández did note that Nike’s performance products remain a bright spot, adding “we expect good growth in running and football.” She also concluded that even though the turnaround is progressing slowly, the company is “making the right moves by focusing on sports, rebalancing the product portfolio by increasing newness, and strengthening relationships with wholesale partners, particularly in North America.” The TAG analyst doesn’t expect meaning improvement until Fiscal Year 2028, given weak sales trends in large parts of the firm’s business in sportswear, international and direct-to-consumer.

Nike’s financial guardian joins other high-profile new team members, including Walmart veteran Jane Ewing, who joined this month as chief commercial officer, and former McDonald’s media strategist Michael Gonda, who came on last year as chief communications and strategy officer.

BTIG analyst Robert Drbul said that Hill’s team is being “built for execution and brings sophistication.” The market watcher said that along with Hill, innovation chief Phil McCartney and North America GM Tom Peddie, “we believe this is a healthy blend of new blood and veterans driving the turnaround.”

And while some analysts have pegged $30 as the target price for Nike shares, Drbul’s price target as of Tuesday is $55. He said that Nike’s balance sheet “remains strong and provides significant flexibility as the turnaround progresses,” even if progression is slower than one would like. That combination of minimal leverage and ample liquidity, as well as limited refinancing risk is what “allows management to remain focused on executing the turnaround, instead of managing the balance sheet,” the BTIG analyst concluded.

Drbul also noted that product innovation represents one of the most important catalysts for share price recovery. He expects that Nike’s investor day will provide a better understanding of the innovation pipeline for 2027.

Best of WWD

Sign up for FN’s Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.